You are here

The official soy/rice/nondairy ice cream review! (to be updated)

This is the official review of all the reviews. You review, and I'll update! You can check here (1st post) for a quick reference! It's really long, but they are organized by brand, type, and alphabetically. (1-poor... 4-great)

365 Organic (Whole Foods)
Chocolate
Excellent!  They have very few ingredients and really taste great.  I highly recommend the hot fudge from this site as a topping.  Most excellent... (auntie nono)
Vanilla
Excellent!  They have very few ingredients and really taste great.  I highly recommend the hot fudge from this site as a topping.  Most excellent... (auntie nono)
Almond dream (Taste the dream)
Bites vanilla
These little things are tasty and addictive.  Usually I don't like vegan vanilla ice creams, but with the chocolate coating these didn't have the usual off taste. (lbarte)
Tasty little things. The chocolate coating melts in your mouth, the ice cream itself is regular I guess. It's hard to really taste with the chocolate there. You'd think that have tiny bits of ice cream would make it easier to eat a single serving, but... not so much. (fb)
Cappuccino swirl

Chocolate
We liked this quite a bit. It's really smooth, nice flavor. (AC)
I don't usually eat sweets, much less frozen, store-bought stuff; however, my mom bought a carton of this to bring to DH's birthday party in case I ran out of the big container of So Delicious.  I love this stuff!  It has a nice, smooth chocolate flavor (not just sweet) and a texture that sort of reminds me of gelato vs. ice cream.  Not icy, foamy (know what I mean?  some soy ice creams do this if they get warm), or 'low fat' fasting.  In fact, I've eaten a 1/3 of a pint while searching for this review thread.  I wish that they wouldn't include soy lecithin in the ingredients.  I'm not soy-intolerant, but it sort of reminds me how MSF adds 'less than 1%' of egg whites to their veggie meats to make them not vegan.  An annoyance. (mdv)
Lil dreamers vanilla

Praline crunch
Yum!! Excellent. I used this in some almond cookie ice cream sandwiches, and it was so good. Good praline flavor, nice texture. (AC)
Love it! Not skimpy with the nuts and very creamy. I was surprised by how good it was. (laurb)
Vanilla
This is good, but it has a bit of an alcohol-y taste. P detected it more than I. Much better when softened a bit. Not super special, but good flavor. (AC)
Coconut Bliss
Cappuccino

Cherry amaretto

Chocolate hazelnut fudge
I was excited to try this though leery of the coconut.  It did have a very faint coconut flavor but overall the creamy chocolate flavor combined with the occasional nut pieces and stripes of fudge was great.  It melted slightly and had a smooth consistency which are both important when trying to replicate dairy ice cream.  Overall I would rate this a 4 out of 5 stars.  Great flavor, good texture and believability.  My only point off is the coconut flavor, though faint, which I really am not a fan of. (Cali)
Wow, this is good.  I can't detect much coconut, but the chocolate and hazelnut is enough for me.  It has a great consistency and tastes super rich. (icephrosty)
Quite good, but not as AMAZING as I was hoping (for $5.99). I love coconut, so not enough coconut for me. The chocolate flavor and texture was great, and there were quite a few large hazelnut pieces. Maybe could have used more "fudge." Really enjoyed it, but wouldn't get again unless on sale. (AC)
Chocolate peanut butter

Chocolate walnut brownie

Coffee
So good.  I give 5 stars to both (and dark chocolate). The real plus is that they contain all natural ingedients. Coconut milk, agave syrup, coffee, chocolate, vanilla. mostly from fair trade sources and most organic. (tk2dsky)
Dark chocolate
Highly recommended! i decided to give it a try because i was using my 7% off day at the co-op and HOLY MOTHER it is good. i was skeptical because i am not always the biggest fan of coconut, but YUM. p.s. bites eaten during this post: 4 (Hesp)
I have completely converted over to coconut bliss! So much better than soy based ice creams. It is creamy, tastes natural, no funky soy aftertaste. So far I have tried the dark chocolate...it's divine. (tk2dsky)
This is quite possibly the best ice cream I've ever had in my entire life including non-vegan ice cream. It is just so creamy and luscious and DARK CHOCOLATEY! It tastes best if you let it sit out for a bit and get just a little melty.  My only regret is that it doesn't seem to be available on the East Coast. (wassernixe)
Dark chocolate bars

Ginger cookie caramel

Mint galactica
Finally a coconut ice cream that does NOT taste of coconut!  The mint is crisp and flavorful without being overpowering.   The creamy ice cream was smooth and light.  The chocolate flakes were perfect, small yet numerous and richly flavored.  Finally a mint chocolate chip non soy ice cream that is fantastic!  I give this 4.5 stars and will buy this again. (cali)
Finally went for this ice cream. The texture is creamier than the other coconut ice creams I've had (So Delicious, Trader Joe's), and sure enough it seems to be higher in fat/calories than those. Anyway, it has less of a coconut taste than the other types of coconut ice cream, and when thawed, it doesn't actually melt but has the texture of whipped cream or something (I left mine out too long and discovered this...). Not overly sweet, and plenty of little bit of chocolate. The mint flavor isn't super strong either, which is good because sometimes I'm afraid of mint chip being toothepasty. It's good, and I'd get other varieties of this brand. (fb)
Mocha maca crunch

Naked almond fudge

Naked coconut
I picked up a pint of this today, and it's so coconutty, creamy, and fabulous!  I love that this is vegan, agave-sweetened, and soy-free. (Sure, I eat natural sugars and soy, but variety is always nice.)  I look forward to trying their other flavors:  dark chocolate, vanilla island, mint galactica, cappucino, cherry amaretto, strawberry lemon love, and chocolate hazelnut fudge. (willwolf)
Naked coconut bars

Pineapple coconut

Strawberry lemon love

Vanilla island
This is the creamiest vegan ice cream I've eaten.  It has a strong coconut flavor with a hint of vanilla.  It tasted like an island vacation.  I'm guessing the "coconut milk" listed in the ingredients is more like coconut cream/butter. A 1/2 cup serving has 210 calories / 14 g fat / 13 g saturated fat / 18 g carbs / 2 g protein.  I know any type of ice cream isn't health food, but the amount of saturated fat is a concern. (hh)
Double Rainbow
Blueberry

Chocolate sorbet
I get it at Trader Joe's and I love it. It has a deep and rich chocolate flavor and the texture is much much more creamy than I expected. I actually like it better than any of the chocolate ice creams I've tried. And only 120 calories per serving! (laurb)
Cinnamon caramel

Coconut sorbet

Lemon sorbet

Mango tangerine sorbet

Mint chocolate chip

Raspberry sorbet

Vanilla bean

Very cherry chip

FreeZees
Crispee cashew sweedee pie

Coconut fudge sweedee pie

Coconut pecan sweedee pie

Fudgee fudge

No-butter pecan

Peanut caramel
I really liked the taste of this, but it was a solid block when it came out of the freezer.  You really have to let it sit for a good 10 minutes before digging in...definitely do not use the micro to speed things up because it will melt in the bottom while the top stays hard (speaking from experience). (icephrosty)
Strawberry delight

Vanilla
it is cashew based and has quinoa in it.  also, it's agave sweetend. in terms of taste i thought it was pretty ok, but the texture doesn't compare to that of coconut milk ice cream (to me). i would recommend buying it and trying it out. actually, it is the best non-dairy vanilla i have tried! (hespedal)
Kidz Dream (Taste the dream)
Berry blast smoothie

Orange creme smoothie

Living Harvest Tempt
Chocolate fudge
Ok. This. This is really, really good. P said it's the BEST ICE CREAM HE'S EVER HAD. EVER. The chocolate flavor is perfect, and the texture is perfect. It's creamy, and firm. Hey, it could use more fudge (just like a couple swirls in there), but it doesn't even matter. Just the chocolate is enough. He said Tempt will be a weekly buy. No hemp taste. (AC)
Coconut lime
Yum! This is tasty and refreshing. The flavor reminds me of a great snow cone, but much better. P said there wasn't a lot of lime flavor in the top portion, but I thought it was great. It has nice toasty coconut pieces, great coconut, and lime flavor, Plus, it's creamy! I think this flavor is just under the chocolate fudge flavor, but above the others. (AC)
It was the best ice cream I'd ever had flavorwise, vegan or non vegan. I did have to microwave it a little, because it was a bit solid when it first came out of the freezer. (dragonfly)
Coffee biscotti
This is not nearly as good as the chocolate fudge, but the coffee flavor is good, and the texture is still good. The biscotti pieces are not biscotti-like, and there's some flavor that's off. The ice cream is good, overall, though; just not a favorite. (AC)
The coffee flavor is definitely strong (in a good way.)  I wish there had been more biscotti chunks!  Also, the chunks were too soggy IMHO.  I'd eat this again if someone else bought it. (icephrosty)
4 1/2 points of yumness. The coffee flavor was spot on, the texture is iceblock hard when you first take it out of the freezer (or that might be my freezer) but once it sits for a bit it's a creamy, dense dessert. This would be more aptly named Coffee Brownie, that's what the biscotti tastes like, which is fine with me. Even if I were a dairy-eater I think I would prefer this over a Ben+Jerry's coffee for flavor. (aggplanta)
Mint chip
I think this is kind of weird. I'm not a huge fan of mint ice cream, but this has an odd (yogurtish) flavor. The mint flavor is not quite right, and the chocolate doesn't help much. P loves mint stuff, and he likes it, but did initially state the yogurt thing. (AC)
Vanilla bean
It's sweet and satisfying, but not my favorite.  Don't get me wrong, I still plan to try every flavor!  My biggest complaint is that it gets super hard in the freezer...I had to nuke it for 30 seconds before I could even wedge a spoon in there!  DH said "this is just ok, the coconut milk stuff is better". (icephrosty)
really good. nice and creamy and, to me, didn't taste hemp-y, which is my mian complaint with vanilla flavors of non-dairy ice creams (you can taste the base flavor too much). dustin said that he thought it definitely had a hemp taste, though, so i don't know who you want to believe. we both thought it was amazingly delicious, though, and continued to eat it even after we got tons of beach salt water in it. (hesp)
This is a good vanilla. It's very vanilla-y, and sweet. It's creamy, but with no aftertaste. It might taste slightly like yogurt, but a really good yogurt. All of these flavors are good. (AC)
Mudslinger's
Freestyle Memphis mudd pie
I love to dunk cookies in milk, tea or coffee, and especially love the coffee-soaked cookie bits at the bottom of my cup. That's what this ice cream flavor reminds me of. (saskia)
Memphis mudd pie
tastes like a cup of Irish Cream coffee with Oreo cookie bits floating around after you've had your fun dunking. This rich and creamy dessert is made with coconut milk, coffee, fudge swirls, chocolate cookie bits and a touch of whiskey. A CBS Channel 5 taster said he was "wickedly, wickedly impressed ... " with it, according to the label. And I was too after I enjoyed it at Maggie Mudd's during the San Francisco Sconefest! meet-up. (At Maggie Mudd's this flavor is called "The Dubliner.") I was so excited to find it at Whole Foods. This is not a light sorbet, or rice ice cream. It's full fat. Full flavor. And fantastic. In fact, this might be my new favorite ice cream flavor. (saskia)
NadaMoo
Creamy coconut

Gotta do chocolate

Lotta mint chip
Yuck! It had a weird bitter taste, almost chemically. Not sure if maybe it was the mint flavoring or the agave, which I've never tried before. I will not get this again. (nmpixie)
Mmmm maple pecan
the texture of this was just way too icy for me.  I really like the creamy stuff and I had high hopes for this flavor.  The maple taste was nice but there weren't enough pecan chunks. (icephrosty)
Vanilla

Natura
Chocolate

Maple

Strawberry

Vanilla

Organic nectars cashewtopia gelato
Cherry chocolate

Chocolate

Chocolate hazelnut

Mint chocolate

Pistachio
THIS IS SO GOOD EVERYONE GO BUY IT. It was $6.99 at my Whole foods and totally worth it. It is seriously the best thing ever. I had second thoughts about buying it but ohmansogood. (sarah)
Love it. (mdv)
Vanilla

Purely Decadent Pints
Anna Banana
3.8 - I thought banana ice cream would be pretty weird, but it was 107 out so I decided to try it anyway. Good stuff! But -.2 points, because I'd rather it have more chocolate. (fb)
Belgian Chocolate
Darker than chocolate ice cream (I suspected black cocoa...) but it tastes pretty much the same. I assumed it would be richer or have a hazelnut tinge because of the "Belgian" part, but hey, it's still chocolate ice cream. 3.5 (fb)
Blueberry Cheesecake
2 stars.  I tried this last night and it was odd.  The blueberry portion tasted slightly chemically?  The taste some dried (preserved) blueberries get.  The 'cheesecake' portion was too sweet for my tastes and the chunks of 'crust' were huge, though tasty. (Cali)
Im hooked. Oh my god. its my favorite soy ice cream so far. the mix of cheesecake ice cream and blueberry ice cream is perfect. also there are actually more blueberries than i thought there would be (and there werent dried!) then there were the ''pie crust'' pieces. ah, they taste like snickerdoodle cookies! they are so good! too bad there arent that many in one pint. i kind of dug through the whole thing trying to scoop them out... go try this ice cream!  (brooke)
4 stars. It doesn't have the "tang" of cheesecake, but it was indescribably tasty. No further comments. (fb)
*Drool* OMG! The blueberry ice cream was sooooooo good! Tasted like sweet fresh blueberries and cream--really, totally awesome! The cheesecake chunks were not taht great though--pretty dry, but they can be easily removed! i give this one 9 out of 10! (Cap)
also bought over thanksgiving break, not as good as the snickerdoodle. the blueberry part creeped me out. i didnt like how the blueberry and the cheesecake flavors were separated. 3 stars. (ponycakes)
Cherry Nirvana
Its the best.  I give it a 4! (kelsi)
Is all right, but I wouldn't buy it again.  It just does not properly satisfy my ice cream cravings! (rubyred)
Amazing. Reminds me a lot of Ben and Jerry's Cherry Garcia. (pinkpickles)
Delicious! Very good black cherry flavor, with lots of chocolate shavings. The actual black cherry pieces are more sparse, but the overal flavor is excellent. Probably one of my faves. (AC)
Chocolate Brownie Almond
4! Yum. Chocolate. Brownie. Almond. Yep, yum! (AC)
Chocolate Obsession
4! I've only had a couple of spoons so far..but it's really good. Chocolaty with pieces of chocolate..and swirls. A great chocolate flavor! (AC)
I'd give it about a 3. I liked the chocolate pieces and the chocolate flavor was OK. I just really am not a fan of the really strong Soy Milk aftertaste. At least, I will keep my calorie count down, because just a few bites of this is enough. (wassernixe)
Chunky Mint Madness
4. This is hands down my favorite ice cream EVAR. Mint ice cream, rich chocolate ice cream, and, and!! : brownie pieces!!! (fb)
Coconut Craze
This is the ONLY ice cream of any sort, dairy or otherwise, that I have sat down, and ate the entire pint in one sitting. It's THAT good. If you're a coconut freak like I am. Freakin amazing, I love love love it. (Pink)
delish, but I can't eat too much of it! Lotsa calories, which is dissapointing. (lolkrys)
Cookie Avalanche
I didn't like this either. The texture was off.  I've had much, much better luck with Soy Delicious. (rubyred)
4! We both really like this. It tastes like an ice cream sandwich. It could use more cookie..but can't they all? It's good. I think the texture is the same as all the others! ...but w/ cookie pieces. (AC)
Pretty good, lots of chunks of cookies, but not worth the extra calories - get the So Delicious quart version. 3. (fb)
meh. good, but i wouldnt buy it again. (ponycakes)
Cookie Dough (GLUTEN FREE)
We give it a 3.5. It wasn't as good as I was expecting, but it grew on me as I was eating. I think it needs more chocolate and cookie dough. (AC)
4.5. This was rich.  Lush and full of vanilla bean depth of flavor.  There were chocolate flakes in good quantities with a dark sharp flavor. Then there were pieces of "cookie dough".  These were nice as they were not moist and gooey but they were not hard or too chewy.  Little nuggets of soft lightly cinnamon tasting sugary crystal textured goodness.   Highly recommended. (Cali)
ice cream has a weird taste that takes a little getting used to. i wish there was more cookie dough! (ponycakes)
This must be what heaven would taste like, if it had a flavor. I fell in love at first bite, with just a spoonful of the delicious vanilla base. It only got better from there. The chocolate was delicious and melted on my tongue, and the cookie dough chunks were not too hard, not too soft, and absolutely delicious. I don't like ice creams that have too much stuff in them, but this wasn't too overloaded. The vanilla base was allowed to stand out. Absolute perfection! (veganrun)
Dulce de Leche
so amazing. i had a spoonful last night, and didn't get a lot of the swirl part, but it still tasted caramel-y and delicious. probably my second favorite after peanut butter zigzag. i also didn't notice the kinda weird taste that purely decadent often has, so that's a plus. my mom said it tasted soy-y though. i did not notice such a taste.. (ponycakes)
Key Lime Pie
3 3/4 stars (Cali)
Liked it as much as the carrot cake one. (Lisa)
Mint Chocolate Chip
4 stars!!! (Lisa)
4 It was crisply minty but without that strange green dye job of dairy MCC.  The chocolate was drizzled in quite chunky so every bite had a thin ribbon or flake of rich dark chocolate.  Overall it was cool to the mouth yet creamy, crunchy to the tooth yet easy to eat.  Very yummy in my opinion! (Cali)
Refreshingly minty, not like toothpaste. Could use more chocolate though. 3.5 (fb)
Mocha Almond Fudge
3.7 The fruit sweetened part was strange at first (since this is chocolately), but I got used to it and loved it. (supadupabee)
4 stars!  So creamy, rich with chocolate, almonds and that hint of coffee flavor.  My personal favorite. (Cali)
Super creamy and has a fudgy swirl.  if they added chunks of chocolate or almonds it would make it even better though.. (propinecone)
Peanut Butter Zig Zag
My favorite! (hespedal)
My friend swears by the peanut butter zigzag. (lubi)
Love the Zig Zag. (Lisa)
I really like it, 4. (lotus)
Yum! That is my favorite also. (pp)
I'll give a 3. (PiP)
4. Rich chocolate, and straight up pb in ice cream. (fb)
again, weird taste at first (i think it's this brand that tastes a little weird to me) but whoa. after getting used to it, this was delicious. i LOOOOVED the peanut butter in it. mm. (ponycakes)
Pomegranate Chip
Terribly addicting. (give_blood)
3.5 I do like this flavor with its sharp fruity flavor and lush rich chocolate.  But somehow it just never quite satisfies my ice cream desires.  It is creamy but the taste is so "sorbet" to me I think it tricks my taste buds.  Again the chocolate is drizzled in a thin ribbon so it permeates the pint.  If you really enjoy a fruity flavor over a decadent creamy mouth feel then try this! (Cali)
Is just icky.  I really don't like the texture...  I definitely didn't feel like it was worth the money. (rubyred)
2.5 It was ok... it was somehow tart, but not super pomegranate-tasting.  (fb)
Praline Pecan

Purely Vanilla
3. Pretty good, but it doesn't actually taste that rich; I'd rather get the quart So Delicious because it has fewer calories. (fb)
Rocky Road
My 5 stars pick! Very chocolaty & rich. (Lisa)
Snickerdoodle
Purely amazing. it tastes exactly like snickerdoodle cookie batter, only cold and very creamy. the cinnamon flavor is lovely and strong. i also love that there is an abundance of cookie dough chunks! but really, this ice cream...wow.. soo delicious! (brooke)
4 stars. The ice cream is snickerdoodle flavored, and there are chunks of dough. I would have eaten the whole thing were it not for incredible will power. Doesn't even need chocolate! (fb)
i found this at my whole foods at home over thanksgiving break, ate about a quarter of it, then left it in the freezer for christmas break. unfortunately, when i came back about a month later, my omni mom and little brother had eaten all of it! very delicious with HUGE chunks of cookie dough. buy this if you see it!!! a billion stars! (ponycakes)
So Very Strawberry
2.5 stars. I was hoping for the sweet, uniformly pink strawberry ice cream of the past, but this has actually swirls and bits of strawberry in it. I wasn't up for healthy-ish, but if you are, this is your ice cream. (fb)
Turtle Trails
4. Vanilla + caramel + chocolate-covered pralines. Great stuff when I'm not in *so much* of a chocolate mood. (fb)
Terribly addicting. (give_blood)
This is ok. I really like the vanilla and caramel, but I think the chocolate covered praline peanuts taste a bit weird. It's pretty good, though. Different. (AC)

Purely Decadent made with coconut milk pints
Chocolate
I really liked it, but it is very coconutty, so if you don't like coconut, you probably won't like it. (Lisa)
Really good too (the coconut milk makes it really creamy and it's sweetened with agave syrup). (heat13)
Loved it!  I thought it was better than the vanilla bean (which I also liked). (icephrosty)
I like this a lot better than the cookie dough variety (as weird as that is to say). The coconut flavor is pretty strong at first, but the chocolate is a strong enough flavor that it balances out. Rich, creamy, like full-fat ice cream, but still somehow doesn't have as many calories/fat as full fat would have. Before (after the cookie dough) I was hesitant to try more coconut milk varieties, but now I'll maybe give them all a try. (fb)
out of this world. I agree that it does have a strong coconut flavor but it works with the chocolate. (emmzach)
This is really really good! Creamy, rich, filling, chocolate-y...honestly, I did not detect a strong coconut flavour, but my mum said that she did. Weird...anyways, I really like this. (dannibazaar)
Chocolate brownie almond
Very, very good.  Could use a few more brownie chunks IMHO, but I won't fault it too much for that. (icephrosty)
Chocolate peanut butter swirl
so delicious!!  I rarely buy/eat ice cream, but this was truly amazing!!  However, if I had to pick my least favorite part, I'd say it was the pb swirl, even though there was very little pb in it...the coconut flavor was fairly strong at first, but then I lost track of it...we ate the entire pint last night....I had to get it out of the house! (erinmonster)
Coconut
4! I love coconut so much and this is so rich and creamy.  And I really like how bright white and fluffy it is.  And it doesn't have a weird after taste like I think the So Delicious ice creams have.  And there are only like 4 ingredients, so that's always nice.  I topped mine with chocolate sauce and almonds Smiley  I'm excited to try the chocolate flavor. (kb)
really good and I ate the whole thing in one sitting.  Not as creamy as tofutti, but much healthier. Way expensive, but you are really getting what you pay for because it only had like 5 or 6 ingredients and was made with agave nectar.  How awesome is that!?  Also, theoretically (I'm a fucking monster so I can eat a ton, but for a normal person) the fat content in the coconut milk should help you feel full faster so that you don't eat as much as if it were all sugar.  Just don't inhale it like I did. (veganfilmjunkie)
Cookie Dough
AWESOME!!!!!!!!! Thumbs Up. (heat13)
2 stars. The cookie dough pieces are REALLY sweet and, though I love coconut milk, the ice cream itself had too strong of a coconut taste to me. I could only eat half a serving at a time. (fb)
Yummy! The coconut milk vanillia ice cream was sweet and gentle--a real treat and the added chocolate shavings and dough was excellent! I give it a 7 out of 10! (Cap)
This was my first flavor from the new line and i love it! the coconut flavor is perfect and not too overpowering. the cookie dough is good but of course there is never enough in one pint. the chocolate shavings are delicious though so it doesn't really matter. i would definitely buy it again! (Brooke)
Now this I am really liking. It does have a strong coconut flavor, but it gives the ice cream such a great rich flavor as well. And the chocolate shavings in it are just amazing. This one rates a 4 for sure. (wassernixe)
This is definitely good. The chocolate is great, and the ice cream is EXTRA creamy. It's almost unnaturally creamy, and white. It's good, though. Something had a bit of a strange flavor (from the coconut?), but I'm not sure if it's the ice cream, or the cookie dough. I think it might be the cookie dough. I usually love cookie dough flavor, but the cookie dough wasn't my favorite part of this. I've wanted to try it for a long time, and it was finally on sale. I think I'd buy it again. (AC)
So so sooo good. Its coconuty and yummy! The ice cream is amazing and the cookie dough reminds me of the real ice cream i used to eat. At first i thought the coconut and cookie dough went weird together, but after a few bites, i love it! (sarah)
Meh...  I liked this so much better when it wasn't made with coconut milk. Not really what I was looking for....I like coconut just not in my freaking cookie dough ice cream, thank you very much! (laurenlovesgoodies)
I am eating this right now because they store was out of my fruit-sweetened variety.  I don't love the texture of the ice cream.  Kind of 'foamy?'  The flavor is good - you can definitely taste the coconut - sort of like adding coconut flakes to chocolate chip cookies.  I probably won't buy it again, but it was a fun change. (mdv)
I love this flavor!  The cookie dough is nice and chunky, and it's fun to dig around and find every piece (ok, maybe I should leave some for DH next time).  Definitely tastes coconut-y, but I like that. (icephrosty)
Cookies 'n cream
One word: amazing.  Go buy a pint and eat it until it's gone, then repeat! (icephrosty)
What I've always wanted cookies and cream ice cream to be like!!  I remember always thinking there were never enough cookies, but there are in this one, baby!  And it's just so damn good!  Once again, the coconut flavor is a bit strong at first, but then mellows as you eat it - and you will eat it all!  (erinmonster)
Green tea

Mint Chip
Incredibly refreshing. It's quite pretty too actually, the ice cream is pretty much the purest "snow" white I've seen. And it tastes super natural, not like the fake green mint and chip you find w/ regular dairy ice cream. I'm super excited to try the vanilla, I hope it tastes ridiculously coconutty. (Pink)
Yummie!  The first couple of bites I could taste the coconut, but after that it was wonderful! (gardengirl)
I'm not a huge fan of mint, but this is really good. It's not too minty (still not my favorite, though), and the chocolate is nice (more, more!), but the actual ice cream is pretty much perfect. It's just so creamy, with a hint of coconut, and looks perfect. Our store only has the cookie dough and mint chip flavors. I hope they get more! I love the coconut milk varieties. (AC)
Mocha almond fudge
This is my absolute favorite of all the coconut milk varities.  I love the combination of flavors, and it is sooooo decadent.  I even made a cupcake version because I loved the ice cream so much! (icephrosty)
Passionate mango
not my thing. I was dumb and didn't notice that passion fruit was a predominant flavor and I don't particularly like it. (emmzach)
Pomegranate chip

Turtle trails

Vanilla Bean
It is very tasty but has a strong coconut flavor, so it would never pass for "plain".  Since I love coconut it was awesome! (icephrosty)
I know I reviewed this before, but I just had it again and want to add a few more points.  This ice cream is sooo creamy that it's ridiculous! Also, when I take it out of the freezer it isn't a solid block of ice but can be scooped immediately. (icephrosty)
This was better then I thought it would be.  I'm not a fan of vanilla beans in my ice cream but the flavor is not very strong.  It is more coconut then vanilla but was really good.  It is worth the $6.00. (monkey7)
This is good, very coconutty, and rich...I couldn't eat a large serving at once, which is probably a good thing. (babysgotsauce)
We buy this quite often. I like it with brownies, but on its own it's too coconutty. I also have made an ice cream sandwich with this and two chocolate chip cookies, and it wasn't that great. (orangecreme)
Purely Decadent Novelties
Multipack-Mocha Mania Coated Sandwich
3.5. Both of these are pretty the same to me: rich, decadent, ice cream sandwich, but the chocolate on the outside is kind of greasy (necessity for being frozen?) (fb)
Multipack-Purely vanilla

Multipack-Vanilla Mania Coated Sandwich
Worth every penny.  Yummy! 4! (kb)
3.5. Both of these are pretty the same to me: rich, decadent, ice cream sandwich, but the chocolate on the outside is kind of greasy (necessity for being frozen?) (fb)
Multipack-Vanilla almond

Stickbars singles-Purely Vanilla

Stickbars singles-Vanilla Almond

Rice divine
Banana Fudge
Banana flavored ice cream with fudge. it was realllllly good, although the fudge was sort of accumulated in one lump at the bottom so i had to dig down and then mix it up. could've just been that one pint though. and there wasn't as much fudge as the picture on the carton led me to believe. but anyway, i'd probably buy it again. (laurb)
The ice cream itself reminds me of banana flavored laffy-taffy, which i love! the ''fudge'' is a bit misleading though. my pint has very few swirls of chocolate. i ended up mixing in a bit of pb which made it extra-special. next time, i think im going to stick with the chocolate peanut butter fudge or mud pie. (brooke)
(yes!) DIVINE (haha), and I don't even normally like ricemilk or anything. 4! (fb)
5 out of 5! creamy, delicious, and won't clog your arteries. (PiP)
Carrot Cake
At first I though it was odd but after a couple bites I really started to like it.  It had a strong carrot cake taste for sure with little chuncks of carrot cake evenly distributed.  My friend thought it was pretty good too and described it as tasting like pumpkin bread batter. I would give this a 4 out of 5 and I don't even like rice milk, I think it is too watery. (becka3)
5 stars from smooch- it's his favorite! (Lisa)
I thought was a 4. i love the cake pieces (taste like pumpkin gingerbread) and the creamy texture of the ice cream, but i think the overall flavor is very faint. i kept taking another bite hoping my tastebuds would finally recognize the carrot cake/pumpkin ice cream flavor. it was still delicious and i didnt have a problem finishing it! (brooke)
the first "fancy" flavor of ice cream that i've ever tried. sooo good! the ice cream part was a little weird at first, but the chunks of carrot cake or whatever are amazing. the texture is reeeally nice. i would definitely buy this again. four stars out of five because of the initial weirdness of ice cream part. (ponycakes)
Very good, the cake bits are nice and spicy. (Laura)
Yessss. Finally someone makes this flavor. The chunks of cake are delicious and in the perfect proportion, and the rest of the ice cream is tasty. I used to think all things rice milk suck, but now I have been shown I was wrong. (fb)
Chocolate chip

Chocolate covered bars-Chocolate chocolate

Chocolate covered bars-Very vanilla

Chocolate peanut butter fudge
this was ok. not super chocolate-y, but still tasty if the store is out of pb zig zag. 4 stars (ponycakes)
Pretty good, but just like any other chocolate pb ice cream (nothing really stands out... especially versus the carrot cake variety) (fb)
Coconut mango

Key lime pie

Mint chocolate swirl

Mudd pie
Very addictive. the coffee ice cream is very creamy with lots of chocolate fudge swirls (more than their other flavors), bits of almonds, and big chunks of brownie. it can't get much better than that. it is quite rich and the coffee flavor is a bit strong, but i wouldnt mind eating it for breakfast. a definite 5 (brooke)
coffee ice cream!! yumm!! with brownie pieces and chocolate! and almonds (ew, but there arent a lot) i think the good karma rice divine is my favorite brand. it doesnt have a weird taste, and it's lower in calories than the purely decadent stuff. (ponycakes)
Mmmmm. I didn't like rice cream last time i had it, and i didnt even realize this was rice until i got home (it was a dollar less, organic, chocolaty, and vegan; thats all i needed to know) Its so good!!! I ate it soo fast, hah. But chocolate with a tiny bit of coffee, really yummy! (sarah)
I thought it tasted weird with the first bite, but then it grew on me. It's a nice balance of flavors with the coffee, caramel, vanilla, and some chocolate. I thought the brownie pieces were the weak point, as they were pretty flavorless. P enjoyed it quite a bit. The coffee flavor is good. (AC)
I didn't know what Mud Pie was when I bought it and there's no description on the carton, but was glad I tried it out because it was great! Coffee and chocolate and caramel. Very good flavor. (laurb)
Sundae cups-Fudge swirl

Sundae cups-Strawberry swirl

Very cherry
This stuff is tasty!  I split a pint wit my husband and he really liked it too!  Creamy and delicious, with real cherry chunks in it.  Good texture, no funny aftertaste.  Everything ice cream should be.  I give it 4 out of 4 stars (karmafreekitchen)
Very vanilla

Rice Dream (Taste the dream)
Cappuccino

Carob

Carob almond

Cherry vanilla

Chocolate

Chocolate frozen pies
this is my favorite frozen pie. The cookies stand out better, and the chocolate ice cream flavor is there. mmm. 300+ calories and 8 g of sat. fat....not something we'll be buying often! (AC)
Cocoa Marble Fudge
2.5-3 I've only had a couple of bites..and the flavor is pretty good, but there's this weird alcohol taste/burn afterward! We were like huhhhhh. Then I looked in the ingredients, and it has chocolate liqueur! I wouldn't think that would taste so alcohol-y....and it's a bit strange! ...I'd like to change my rating to a 3.2....the alcohol taste goes away after a while, and it's actually pretty good.. (AC)
Cookies N Dream

Ice cream bites
These little things are addicting!  I love that you can open the freezer and pop just one (or two) in your mouth. With regular ice cream, I'm always tempted to have a huge bowl instead of a few spoonfulls.  The hard chocolate shell gives them a nice bite. (icephrosty)
Not as good as the almond ones. The rice ice cream tastes more watery, and almost has a sort of tanginess to it? I like the fact that it's in little bites, but I definitely prefer the almond to this. (fb)
Mint carob chip

Mint chocolate frozen pies
I don't really like this much, but I'm not a big fan of mint things. P really loved it. I mean, there's nothing wrong with it (it's not you, it's me). (AC)
Mocha frozen pies
this one is really good. At first, I thought the chocolate covering was overpowering, but that's just on the outer edges..if you get a good middle bite..it's really good. The cookies don't come through much, but that's all right. (AC)
I like these a lot, actually, and I've gotten them quite a few times. It seems like different flavors come through more (chocolate, ice cream, cookie) with different ones, but they are all good. (AC)
These are the best! I get one every time I go to the co-op (and usually eat it on my way home) shameful! (babysgotsauce)
Neapolitan
I love this flavor! It reminds me of being a kid and just trying to scoop out the chocolate part, although now I want all the flavors together! (babysgotsauce)
Orange vanilla swirl
This is good. I guess it tastes like a creamsicle. P thought he could taste a "brown rice aftertaste," but he didn't mind it. Good overall. (AC)
Strawberry
I didn't really like it, it had a funky aftertaste and texture. It also required microwaving. (dragonfly)
Vanilla
Really good! (awildfire)
This was good, but not great.  I'm still on the lookout for the perfect vegan vanilla ice cream.  This had a very pronounced tangy flavor that tasted more like frozen yogurt.  Although it has 8 grams of fat per serving, it's very lacking in the creaminess department.  It is smooth, but not creamy.  No objectionable flavors - I didn't like the vanilla So Delicious, and this is a better option.  It does taste like rice, but I think it's a good combination with the vanilla. With all that fat, though, I'd rather have something that tastes more indulgent. (vegrunski)
Not a fan. Its too heavy tasting, I'm not big on the texture nor the taste. (dannibazaar)
I thought this was pretty good. I would get it again for a vanilla. There's just a hint of that rice..taste, but I don't mind it. P really liked this, and liked the rice taste. (AC)
Vanilla bars with chocolate coating

Vanilla frozen pies
I don't remember the actual name, but it's made with rice cream, oatmeal cookie sandwiches and carob shell. Absolutely delicious. I eat them rarely because they're like 400 calories a pop, but they're worth it. (ledzepfan)
Vanilla nutty bars

Vanilla Swiss almond

Rice dream supreme
Cappuccino almond fudge

Chocolate caramel chai
The texture isn’t quite right… grainy. More like a rough sorbet than ice cream. Could have been a bad batch. Anyway, the taste was uncommonly good. I can only get it at my local HFS, though, which means it’s a good bit more expensive than I’d like. (narcissus)
Pralines n dream

Vanilla hazelnut fudge
I just saw this yesterday and decided to give it a try because it sounded so amazing - and it did not disappoint!  The flavor was great and it was nice and creamy.  I think it's a little skimpy on the hazelnuts and fudge but I was willing to dig around for them.  This was my first experience with rice milk ice cream and I'm definitely impressed.  I made DH a shake with it and he loved it too. (babysgotsauce)
Seattle Sorbet
Champagne orange

French chocolate
This "sorbet" is actually coconut milk based, which lends a creamy texture.  It has a rich chocolate flavor.  A big plus is that it's available at a regular grocery store that I shop at, and is much less expensive than other vegan ice creams at that store (almost half the price!).  Very nice for impulse ice cream purchases. (vegrunski)
Raspberry nectarine

So Delicious
Butter Pecan
3. I enjoy the fake butter flavor (doesn't taste real at all to me, but I like that), but I'm not crazy about the amount of pecans in here. I guess I just want butter-flavored ice cream! (fb)
Chocolate Peanut Butter (regular and fruit sweetened)
3.8! Yum! (Laura)
4. (lotus)
3.2. It's pretty good, but since it's the quart-size lower-fat kind that So Delicious makes, it's lighter on flavor than the Purely Decadent variety.But good if you don't want something super heavy. (fb)
Doesn't seem to have enough flavor. (icephrosty)
The sweetness just wasn't there for me.  The peanut butter part was better than the chocolate.  I have a whole quart of it so I guess I need to use it up.  Maybe I can make it into a milkshake with some chocolate soy milk to up the flavor. (biodancer)
4. The chocolate by itself is not particularly grand....but the peanut butter is really good. Great, overall! (AC)
SO GOOD. its dangerous. (it sort of tastes like oreos dipped in peanut butter!) (brooke)
4!  I thought that fruit sweetened and peanut butter/chocolate would be gross, but it was really good!  (kb)
NEEDS MORE PEANUT BUTTER! It was so good, but if only there were more strips (or do you call them ribbons?) of PB. I love it though, and will consume it speedily. (Laura)
At first I thought it didn't look chocolaty enough for me, but I loved it. It is very light tasting, almost like a soft serve I had a hard time putting it away without eating it all- I'll give it 4 stars! (Lisa)
(fruit sweetened) I love its creamy texture. The peanut butter part of it tastes better than the chocolate, which is still good, not too rich and sweet. Tastes very good with banana slices. (Saskia)
Chocolate Velvet
2.5. I don't really remember much about it, but I think it was kind of weird. (AC)
2.7. It's yummy, but if I'm going to eat soy ice cream... (Laura)
Trying it the second time, i absolutely love it. maybe because i havent had chocolate ice cream in a while and i was craving chocolate? i'm not sure. but it was delicious and very rich. i actually had my omnivore father try it and he couldnt tell the difference and really enjoyed it. i still want to try whole soy frozen yogurt but i cant find it! for now, so delicious will have to do! (brooke)
Decent, similar to chocolate oatscream. (brooke)
1.  Yuck.  I'm not a fan.  Bad aftertaste that even chocolate syrup can't disguise. (kb)
I reviewed it already, but I don't really think I remembered it. It's ok....not spectacular..but it's pretty good...like a 3. (AC)
2.5 It's pretty light in the calories/fat, and you can tell, but it's all right. My only problem with it is that it gets hard/freezer burnt in the freezer more quickly than all the other ice creams (except the vanilla), so eat it fast! (fb)
Cookies 'N Cream
4 stars(lubi)
4!!! (Lisa)
4. Oh, so so good. SO YUMMY. I wonder if I have some left in my freezer... (Laura)
Ok flavor and texture. (pinkpickles)
Creamy Vanilla
1.  Yuck.  I'm not a fan.  Bad aftertaste that even chocolate syrup can't disguise. (kb)
3.5. This was our first flavor, and it was good. It has great vanilla flavor, and our omni friend couldn't tell the difference between it and dairy ice cream. (AC)
4. Mmm. This was pretty tasty... Good enough on its own, but also topped with fruit, cookie crumbles, syrups, with cake Smiley (Laura)
3.This was a good ice cream.  But I found it to be more icy than creamy.  The vanilla was a good flavor but was not very deep.  Just a rather basic taste.  This would be good in sundaes and under sauces but honestly it just did not do much for me.  Luckily there was no preservative taste or else its score would have been lower! (Cali)
3. Good vanilla flavor, but you can tell it's low fat/calorie. It quickly freezer-burns, so eat it fast! (fb)
Dulce de Leche

Mint Marble Fudge
Meh. the first time i had it i hated it a lot. like a lot a lot. it tasted like frozen water with a soy after taste and some weird gummy chocolate in it. second time was slightly better, but not something id buy again 1.4 (ponycakes)
Ugh.  Agreed.  I did NOT like this one at all. (kb)
We like this ok. I bought the quart on sale. I think we actually kind of miss that green, artificial color! I've never been a fan of mint ice cream, but it was one of P's favorites. Not near enough fudge..and it's just ok. I'm glad we tried it. (AC)
This was just alright, definitely would not repurchase. Would be better with chunks of chocolate or fudge instead of swirls of liquid fudge. The texture didn't impress me. (pinkpickles)
Mocha Fudge
3. Pretty tasty, but just not my favorite ice cream... dunno why. (fb)
(quart) Um. Really good. 4. It tastes just I remember mocha flavored things..tasting. It's mocha-y...probably could use more fudge, but it's good. I wonder if the pint is better? Seems to be the case for other flavors. (AC)
Neapolitan
4. This is my favorite so far. The strawberry is grand, so I'm guessing the plain strawberry flavor would also be really good.  (AC)
3.7. It's the first kind I've ever tried, and it's near and dear to my heart. (Laura)
It's not my favorite but I will definitely eat the rest. (icephrosty)
Just didn't seem as good as the pints that we had before....I dunno, the strawberry was EXCELLENT before, and this one is just kinda..ok. The chocolate part seems a lot better though. I dunno. (AC)
Yuuuuuuuuum. She got her cous cous and veggie soup from the bar and I sat there and ate half the container of ice cream. 4 4 4 4 4 4 (SoG)
(quart) I actually really like this flavor. The combination of all three flavors is great and surpasses the plain chocolate velvet, strawberry, and vanilla. It's very simple, but I would definitely buy it again. (brooke)
I love love love this with brownies. The strawberry is the best, I like the chocolate, and I don't care as much for the vanilla, though it complements the other two flavors quite nicely. This is my favorite non-dairy ice cream. (orangecreme)
Strawberry
It's really light, creamy, and sweet. i love anything strawberry, so im not dissapointed. im looking forward to having a bowl with fresh sliced strawberries mixed in. or even making a smoothie. (brooke)

So Delicious agave sweetened mini fruit bars
Orange passion fruit

Raspberry

Strawberry

0 likes

So delicious all natural sandwiches
Chocolate

Minis chocolate

Minis mint

Minis neapolitan
They were good.  What's the rating system, out of four?  Three I guess.  I have nothing to compare to.I was kind of disappointed in that all three sections of the neapolitan are the same flavor to me.  I very much like distinct strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate.  But that just might be my not paying attention.  They are cute and little and I like that they are small.  Taste pretty much how I remember dairy ice cream to taste when I ate it a year ago.  Sooo yeah.  Good times. (KMK)
Yummy! Not a huge fan of the strawberry bit, but the vanilla and choclate in the middle are divine. (Laura)
They taste just like I remember ice cream sandwiches!  They don't get too hard in the freezer and they're well wrapped to avoid freezer burn.  These are definitely worth a try.  I like all three flavors of ice cream, but I wish they'd make a chocolate PB version!! (icephrosty)
delicious, good texture, the chocolate sandwich layers are perfect & i really like the portion controlled size.  it's satisfying even though it's small. heh.. (propinecone)
Minis pomegranate

Minis vanilla

Vanilla

So Delicious Coconut Water Sorbet
Hibiscus

Lemonade

Mango

Raspberry
Very creamy and flavorful. Good alternative to Popsicles with only 60 calories each. (sharpenup)
So Delicious Fruit Sweetened
Almond Pecan
It's ridiculous! (Ridiculously good!) So sweet - it tastes like maple walnut ice cream. My head's spinning just thinking about it. (Laura)
Very good, definitely not skimpy on the nuts. However the ice cream part was more like water ice, imo. not creamy. Good for a "butter pecan" craving. 3 (laurb)
At first this is overwhelmingly sweet, but it really grew on me. Tastes like a cross between butter pecan and pistachio. Overall, I really like it but its so sweet that I can only tolerate a few spoonfuls at a time. (pinkpickles)
Awesome Chocolate
Wow! this is more than awesome! softened at room temp it tastes like a rich velvety chocolate mousse. its my new favorite!! (Brooke)
Black Leopard
4 stars. (mdvegan)
Carob Peppermint (discontinued?)
Is my favorite.  I give it a 4 and can't get enough of it! (rubyred)
Sooooo good and not too bad for you either (~115 cal for 1/2 cup)! (icephrosty)
I keep going back to the carob/peppermint! (icephrosty)
Chocolate Almond

Chocolate Peanut Butter (regular and fruit sweetened)
3.8! Yum! (Laura)
4. (lotus)
3.2. It's pretty good, but since it's the quart-size lower-fat kind that So Delicious makes, it's lighter on flavor than the Purely Decadent variety.But good if you don't want something super heavy. (fb)
Doesn't seem to have enough flavor. (icephrosty)
The sweetness just wasn't there for me.  The peanut butter part was better than the chocolate.  I have a whole quart of it so I guess I need to use it up.  Maybe I can make it into a milkshake with some chocolate soy milk to up the flavor. (biodancer)
4. The chocolate by itself is not particularly grand....but the peanut butter is really good. Great, overall! (AC)
SO GOOD. its dangerous. (it sort of tastes like oreos dipped in peanut butter!) (brooke)
4!  I thought that fruit sweetened and peanut butter/chocolate would be gross, but it was really good!  (kb)
NEEDS MORE PEANUT BUTTER! It was so good, but if only there were more strips (or do you call them ribbons?) of PB. I love it though, and will consume it speedily. (Laura)
At first I thought it didn't look chocolaty enough for me, but I loved it. It is very light tasting, almost like a soft serve I had a hard time putting it away without eating it all- I'll give it 4 stars! (Lisa)
(fruit sweetened) I love its creamy texture. The peanut butter part of it tastes better than the chocolate, which is still good, not too rich and sweet. Tastes very good with banana slices. (Saskia)
Espresso
Definitely contains espresso. Not as sweet as I thought it would be, but that's good!. 3. (fb)
Green Tea
Amazing! (fb)
Ew! We don't drink tea....but this tasted gross. I'm sure it's a personal taste thing...but........yuck. We're gonna try chocolate syrup. (AC)
Mango Raspberry
FREAKIN GOOOOOD! oh my god! i ate the whole pint.....in like, less than 10 minutes, i swear.best "ice cream" i've EVER had! (sirensong)
Pistachio Almond
4!! Absolutely fantabulous! I've always love pistachio ice cream, but I don't like the fake green color. This one is white, and it's freakin perfect. So good w/ the almond pieces. (Pink)
gets very high marks. My spoon scoops right into its creamy texture, studded with roasted almond bits. Made with organic soymilk, it is fruit-sweetened(pineapple and apple syrups, pear and peach concentrates) with vanilla and chicory root extracts. It really is much better than those hard-to-scoop, chemically-greened pistachio ice creams I remember from my childhood. This ice cream tastes fabulous alone. It would also complement birthday cake, Baklava or pie a la mode quite nicely. (Saskia)
Raspberry
4. This is Patrick's favorite. I think it's good too-very raspberry-y...and low fat/calorie! (AC)
2. I didn't like this one so much. It was tasty, but seemed... I don't know. I'd rather have just plain sorbet, or make my own frozen raspberry treat. (Laura)
Its delicious and it reminds me of gelato in texture. also i love the raspberry swirls which add a bit of tartness to the sweet raspberry! (Brooke)
3. At times the real raspberry flavor was weirdly addicting, and at other times it was just ok (?). My mother LOVED it though. (fb)
My mom loves this and she's not even vegan. (Saskia)
Tiger Chai
This stuff tasted great. What a marvelous summer treat. It kind of had the same aftertaste of this toothpaste I used as a child. It's still really good. I liked that toothpaste.  (Courth)
Vanilla
This is the first soy vanilla ice cream ive tried so i dont have much to compare to. i didnt have high expectations, but i thought it was actually really good! the vanilla bean flavor is strong which i love and its also very creamy. and so light. i think its wonderful plain but i cant wait to try it with hot fugde or fresh berries. yum! (Brooke)
This was really good. Well, I don't have any vegan ice cream to compair it to so...I can't say it's better or worse than anything else. I think that it was really nice and light, with great flavour. The texture reminded me a little bit of sorbet. I'd like to try more flavours, but sadly this is the only flavour available that is fruit sweetened in my local groceries (dannibazaar)
Vanilla Fudge

So Delicious Kidz Pops
Fruit pops

Fudge pops

So delicious made with coconut milk novelties
Banana split
4. I was taking a risk at $5/box, but it was well worth it! It didn't have an overwhelming coconut flavor, it's agave sweetened, only 100/calories, and includes banana/strawberry/chocolate ice cream. The chocolate's so good I'm thinking of branching out and trying their coconut milk pints. These sure didn't taste like only 100 calories. (fb)
Smooth, creamy but with a very pronounced coconut flavor.  Only the chocolate was non coconuty.  The strawberry was almost overwhelmingly coconut flavored.   The cookie was a good texture and held up well.  Overall I would rate it a 4 for people that like coconut. Personally, I am not a fan of the flavor so I feel for me, its a 2. (Cali)
I like these a lot.  They are the perfect size for a quick sweet snack.  The flavor is very close to a banana split too. So little calories and fat but such a bold flavor. (monkey7)
So good! These are pretty much perfect. I didn't taste any coconut at all, but thought all of the flavors are good. The banana stands out (as it would in a banana split), and the strawberry is best. The sandwich is good, and they are so cute. They are expensive, but I would get these again. (AC)
Coconut

Coconut almond
These ice cream bars are sooo good!  They're a perfect size and come 4 to a package.  The coconut ice cream is super creamy and luscious.  The chocolate/almond coating is also quite tasty.  I like that the coconut ice cream center is agave sweetened (although the chocolate/almond coating does contain beet sugar).  I love these! (willwolf)
SO GOOD. Go buy them. Now! I think it was 3 (more maybe) dollars for them (4 in a box), which is a good deal, seeing as i pace myself eating this as compared to pints where i'll just eat the whole thing. Oh! Theres coconut in the chocolate too! Mmmmm (sarah)
I didn't think these were that great! P said the coconut flavor was strong to him, but I couldn't really taste it at all (and I like coconut). These tasted like a regular chocolate ice cream bar thing to me. I mean, it's good (chocolate, nuts, ice cream), but not special. I would much prefer the mini sandwiches, especially since these are only 4 to a box. All the components taste good, but nothing spectacular. (AC)
The next one had a lot more coconut flavor, and it was so much better! I really enjoyed that one. (AC)
Organic minis fudge

Vanilla minis bar
Delicious!  The chocolate is really, really good and the ice cream is so, so creamy.  Way better than any dairy ice cream bar I've had.  5 out of 5 *Disclaimer* I LOVE coconut, so maybe someone who didn't wouldn't like these so much, but I think they are fabulous! (kb)
Vanilla minis sandwich

So delicious made with coconut milk no sugar novelties
Fudge bar

Vanilla bar

So delicious no sugar added
Butter pecan

Chocolate

Mint chip

Toasted almond chip

Vanilla bean

So Delicious Novelties
Big buddy

Chocolate sandwich

Chocolate chip

Creamy fudge Bar
Cheap vegan frozen novelties. Yes indeed! (Laura)
4. Low calorie AND chocolatey AND tasty. Pretty melty though (no white pants). (fb)
Yum.  Not many calories but still a cold and delicious treat.  A little on the expensive side but I think these are worth the splurge on ocassion.  (icephrosty)
Creamy orange bar
creamy, light, light orange flavor. really good for a 'creamsicle' craving. (fb)
Creamy raspberry bar
I would have to give this a 2. I was never really into creamsicles when I ate dairy and I guess I am still not so into them! This was okay, but it has a sort of sour taste to it. I felt like I was eating frozen raspberry cream cheese or something.  (stillflat)
a little too tangy for me. the orange one has a better overall flavor. (fb)
Creamy Vanilla Bar
Pretty darn tasty! (Laura)
Li'l Buddies Chocolate

Li'l Buddies Mint

Li'l Buddies Peanut Butter

Li'l Buddies Vanilla

Mint sandwich

Mint Chocolate Chip
It was to die for!  It is mint chocolate ice cream sandwiched between two delicious double chocolate chip cookies.  The label even said it had 4 grams of fiber, and I was impressed that I was actually full after I ate it.  Normally I just want more ice cream after I treat myself to some!  I would recommend this product to everyone. (rubyred)
Mint Mania Coated Sandwich
Im not really a fan of mint ice cream but these are really good.  (sharpenup)
Mocha Mania Coated Sandwich
Former favorite frozen treat (see key lime pie cuties). These are absolutely delicious. (sharpenup)
Neapolitan sandwich

Vanilla and Almonds
3 We wanted to try some bars..and they were pretty good. They were definitely not worth the money (3 bars). (AC)
Vanilla Sandwich
3.7. I actually like these better than the tofutti cuties; they're lighter and less syrupy, and they're larger. The wafer part isn't quite as chocolatey, but I forgive them for that. (fb)
So good
Boysenberry swirl

Butterscotch swirl

Chocolate supreme

Cone chocolate

Cone vanilla

Creamy vanilla

Simply strawberry

Soy Dream
Butter pecan
I just searched through an entire pint of Soy Dream Butter Pecan to look for the pecans...there were none! The picture on the carton and the description show many pecans in the ice cream but my carton was just vanilla-ish ice cream that was pretty tasteless. Was I wrong to assume that there should be pecans in with the ice cream? Or did I just get a dud? (laurb)
Chocolate fudge brownie
this is the first time ive tried soy dream and im impressed! the texture is very creamy and the flavor is amazing; extreme chocolate with nice chunks of brownie bites. if you want the perfect substitute for ben and jerry's chocolate fudge brownie, this is it. i love it! (brooke)
*drool* I've died and gone to brownie ice cream heaven, I only had 2 spoonfuls but its very very good!!! (sarah)
I think we've had this before, but never reviewed it. I guess we won't be having it again, because it's discontinued at the store. I think it's good, but with a slight off taste. Mine was also kind of icy, which didn't help the texture. The overall flavor is good, and the brownie pieces are good and plentiful. (AC)
French vanilla

Mocha fudge

Green tea
I like this. I always think there could be more green tea, but this still has a decent amount. Simple, kinda earthy. (fb)
Lil dreamers chocolate

Lil dreamers vanilla

Mocha fudge
Five stars! no really, it's the best flavor by Soy Dream I've tried so far. Great taste, great texture, hardens well in the freezer but softens nicely when left to thaw a little...."Chocolatey-Coffee Orgasm" could be another name for it. (carrotwench)
This is good, but not my favorite for some reason. There's nothing wrong with it. It has good flavor, maybe just not enough swirly stuff, I dunno. I prefer almond/rice ice cream, anyway. The mocha flavor is good, and it has some good fudge parts. (AC)
Vanilla

Vanilla fudge

Sweet nothings novelties
Fudge bar
It was rally good, my only problem was that it wasn't creamy. I do like it better than the fudgesicles I used to eat. I give it 4.2 out of 5 stars. (chickiestripveg)
Mango raspberry

Temptation
Blueberry

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
BEST soy ice cream I've ever had!  Too bad you can only find it in certain cities... (icephrosty)
The best of that flavor i've ever had (vegan or not)  the ice cream itself tasted like it had buttercream frosting in it - amazing. (propinecone)
Ok, so this weekend I ate almost an entire pint of Temptation's Cookie Dough ice cream.  I know I've reviewed it before, but people, if you haven't had it yet then go find some!!  lol, it is THAT good.  I think I left three spoonfulls in the container because I didn't want to be a total pig...but hey, I can't get it where I live!! (icephrosty)
Dreamsicle
Light and yummy - and really good when you dip pretzels in it.. (propinecone)
French vanilla

Home ice cream mix-Chocolate
I got this for my birthday and it's sooo easy to use!  You just add non-dairy milk and a little canola oil and voila!  The chocolate ice cream is really, really good.  I've made it with unsweetened soymilk, ricemilk, and coconut milk and it was heavenly each time.  (icephrosty)
Home ice cream mix-French vanilla

Lemon

Mint Chocolate Chip
Also delicious and actually had little bits of mint in it! (propinecone)
Organic chocolate

Organic coffee

Organic green tea

Pineapple

Peach cobbler

Pumpkin

Soft serve-Chocolate

Soft serve-Vanilla

Strawberry

Triple chocolate threat
Really creamy with lots of chocolatey chunks and what i think is some sorta cookie dough pieces. so good! (propinecone)

0 likes

Tofutti
Better Pecan
Probably one of the most unhealthy things ever (even as ice cream goes), but good for once in a while. i haven't even had this kind lately, i think i'll have to get some to see if it's still that good. (laurb)
Didnt like it. it's partially the texture that creeps me out too. (imaveganpancake)
my mother (an omnivore!) eats this exclusively (like, instead of real ice cream (veganfilmjunkie)
Chocolate Cookie Crunch
3.5 They're a nice little sweet pick me up. (PiP)
Chocolate supreme
2.5 (PiP)
I don't care for this (veganfilmjunkie)
4.5 stars for me, but tofutti is the only brand i have tried yet. it reminded me of pudding pops! (jaynswiss)
Cheesecake supreme-Strawberry cheesecake
nasty, i couldn't get over the chemical-ey taste it had, so its like a 1.5 for me. (jaynswiss)
Cuties-(wild) Berry
4. (fb)
Cuties-Blueberry wave

Cuties-Chocolate wave
4. (fb)
These aren’t quite as good as the vanilla Cuties, but only in the sense that these get four out of four, and the vanilla ones get five out of four. The texture is perfect, the tastes are balanced – no beany taste, no weird sharp sugar flavour… remarkably realistic. (narcissus)
My first cutie. I didn't know they were so small! However, they are good. I don't really have any problems with them..good, creamy ice cream, good cookie sandwich. I don't mind the size, either. (AC)
Cuties-Chocolate peanut butter
Good, doesnt really taste like peanut butter though, My sister though they were coffee cuties. (sharpenup)
Cuties-Coffee break
maybe they don't make them anymore....idk....i haven't seen them in forever, but those were my favorite of the cuties! (sirensong)
Cuties-Cookies 'N Cream

Cuties-Key lime
The most delicious things ever. They are sooooo good. I've never had key lime pie so I don't know what to compare them with but they taste kinda sweet and fresh..ish. (sharpenup)
Cuties-Mint chocolate chip
4. Especially mint chip. (fb)
AMAZING. i love the mint chip ice cream in these. do they make this flavor in pints? these also make a perfect snack when you are sick! (Brooke)
Cuties-Strawberry wave

Cuties-Totally vanilla

Cuties-Vanilla
5 awesome. i ate them before i was vegan, and my omni brothers eat them as well. really good. (ponycakes)
4. (fb)
As a wee bairn, I ate these before I ate real ice cream. So I’m probably biased… but these are one of my all-time favourites. The cookie bit is soft and cakey, not too sweet, with a nice dark chocolate taste. The texture of the ice cream is spot-on. (narcissus)
love. My whole family eats them. Except my brother, but he's a doofus when it comes to food. (courth)
I am in love with these. They taste exactly like I remember ice cream sandwiches tasting. The cookie part is even spot-on. It's the perfect taste and texture. My bf even liked these, and he can be a bit picky about soy ice-cream. They're the only flavor I've tried, so they are pretty much my favorite. (veganrun)
Ice Cream Sandwich Bars
3.5 They're a nice little sweet pick me up. (PiP)
Stick treats-Chocolate dipped mint

Stick treats-Chocolate fudge treats
They are supremely fudgy and much better than fudgsicles. Everyone loved them. (jkl)
In lieu of a review, have an anecdote: I was staying with my sister and her then-husband in California. It was the heat of summer, so she bought me some of these while we were at Whole Foods procuring ‘weird hippie chow.’ Anyway, a few days later, I walked through the front door to find the husband and five of his manliest, most carnivorous friends sprawled in the living room, watching football and… eating tofu popsicles. “These are really good,” one said. “They taste like chocolate pudding.” After I was done staring at them and blinking slowly, I went and got one for myself because… yeah. Tasty. Like chocolate pudding. (narcissus)
Stick treats-Coffee break treats

Stick treats-Hooray hooray

Stick treats-Marry me bars

Stick treats-Mint by mintz

Stick treats-Totally fudge

Vanilla
Really soft and creamy almost like soft serve.  I thought it tasted so much like the cake batter flavor i used to get at coldstone creamery.  Delicious! (propinecone)
I don't care for this, but  sometimes I get plain vanilla anyways and put peanut butter and chocolate syrup and something crunch on it and then it's fine. (veganfilmjunkie)
Vanilla almond bark
really yummy (veganfilmjunkie)
good, but only in an okish, small portions way. mainly because of the almond bark-3. (jaynswiss)
Vanilla fudge

Wildberry supreme
really yummy (veganfilmjunkie)
I had a mild addiction to it for a while. So good. (courth)
Yours truly cone
I saw these at the HFS and had to try them.  Very yummy.  My trash-eating omni friend who was with me at the time ate one and loved it.  It tastes just like I remember a Drumstick tasting minus the cheap peanuts but with cookie crumbs instead.  My only complaint is that the cone was a bit mushy.  I don't think they lined it with enought chocolate.  My daugter loved them but threw the cone away. (lbarte)
Pretty cool. I forgot how much I like the tofutti ice cream despite its apparently horrid ingredients. The chocolate lining the cone was pretty hard to taste though, and the cone itself was kinda soft and chewy (I was expecting hard and crispy like a plain sugar cone). Nice to have this option! (fb)
Trader Joe's
Cherry Chocolate Chip
I ate this and I died...I will move across the country permanently so that I can live near a Trader Joe's and only eat this for the rest of my life. (EarthGuard)
5 stars!! Oh yeah, I forgot about this one.  This Cherry Chocolate Chip is phenomenal!  The flavor of the ice cream is so sweet , creamy, and cherrylicious, and I love that it has the chunks of both cherry and chocolate.  Trader Joe's now has their own label on this ice cream; it's a relabel of the Double Rainbow Soy Cream Very Cherry Chocolate Chip that they've previously stocked.  Another fantastic thing about this ice cream is that it's only $3.69 per quart (yes, QUART!) at TJ's. (WW)
Wow!  Amazing!  I'm not usually a big fan of cherry flavored stuff, but this has big chunks of real cherry AND chocolate!  I would eat this again anytime!! (icephrosty)
We have a quart of this too, Taj's favorite.  I like it too, but not as much as chocolate. (babysgotsauce)
LOVED it! I shared it with an omni friend and she said it tasted like the vegan version of Cherry Garcia and I agree from what I can remember of it. (minke)
Chocolate
I bought a quart on Sunday and it only lasted 4 days!  I used it for shakes and sundaes and it was good.  It does get pretty hard in the freezer but I left it sitting out for ~10 min before scooping and it was the perfect consistency.  For a plain flavor it was tasty. (icephrosty)
I looove this simple chocolate! its delicious and creamy when softened. i will be buying it again and again. (Brooke)
I always have a quart (or two,) of  this in the freezer, my absolute favorite! So Cheap too! (babysgotsauce)
Chocolate coconut
It was delicious. My new favorite! It's also about half the price as the other brands, and just as delicious. (dragonflyi)
Chocolate ice cream sandwiches
not as good as tofutti. kind of have a weird ish flavor, but slightly better for you than tofutti. 2.5 (ponycakes)
I have not tried tofutti's before, but i really like these for a chocolate quick fix. (Brooke)
4. Good, and definitely healthier than tofutti. The wafer is also lighter. (fb)
Very yummy!  Pretty tasty for only 90 cals, and it satisfied my ice cream craving. (icephrosty)
Chocolate made with coconut milk
Omgggg. J thinks this tastes too coconutty, but I think it's fine. Sometimes I can taste the coconut, sometimes not. But the CHOCOLATE. The chocolate flavor here is like straight outta dairy chocolate ice cream. I don't know why it's different. But it's DELICIOUS. (fb)
This stuff is totally awesome! I bought it thinking it would be "meh," but boy, what a wonderful surprise! It's creamy and super chocolatey and just pure yum! It kinda reminds me of the Godiva chocolate ice cream I used to buy, only I honestly like this sooooo much better! This got rave reviews from everyone in my family and will be my go to ice cream from now on. It comes in two flavors, chocolate and strawberry, and sell for $3.99 a pint. It may seem a little pricey, but it's no worse than buying a scoop out. I plan on trying their strawberry this weekend. (abrimmer)
Mochi
My friend and I also tried the vegan mochi from TJ's and we didn't like it. (minke)
I agree with Minke on the mochi. the ice cream part was delicious, but the mochi part didn't even taste or feel like food, let alone the deliciousness that is mochi. I was very sad. They were very pretty though, but not pretty enough to make up for the nasty old rubber texture. (dragonfly)
Mochi chocolate

Mochi coconut
pretty tasty. (fb)
Mochi green tea

Mochi mango

Mochi strawberry

(Soy creamy) orange vanilla bar
Creamy, light, sweet, and taste exactly like an orange dreamcicle! whats not love? (Brooke)
(Soy creamy) Vanilla
Delicious, my parents even like it. i find it less 'icey' and also less expensive than Soy Delicious Vanilla. (propinecone)
Pretty good for a "plain vanilla" ice cream and the price is right.  I always use it for sundaes and everything a la mode! (icephrosty)
Strawberry made with coconut milk
A little tart, tastes of real strawberries. I was kind of hoping for utter fake strawberriness, so on that end I was kind of disappointed since this was higher quality, hahaha. It's probably good for people who want quality, unlike myself. (fb)
Vanilla Mango
Awesome!!  my mom and i devoured a carton in one evening- you can't even tell that its soy- its so creamy and yummy!! (Morbidgrrrl)
Delicious. I haven't had ice cream in a long time and would serve this to omnis too. It's soft and creamy. Not bland. But not too sweet either with a wonderful vanilla taste. Very enjoyable on this hot summer day. (Saskia)
WholeSoy & Co Soy Frozen Yogurt
Black cherry

Chocolate hazelnut
5 stars!!  This is probably the best soy ice cream/frozen yogurt that I've had.  Since this is labeled as "soy frozen yogurt," I was kind of expecting there to be a bit of a tang, but it's completely sweet, just like soy ice cream.  I guess it's considered "soy frozen yogurt" just because they add the live active cultures.  There are no weird or off flavors.  The texture is really creamy.  The flavor is outstanding.  In this chocolate hazelnut offering, the chocolate is the primary flavor, while the hazelnut is more in the background.  This product comes in the small pint containers, but it's so wonderful that I wish it came in a larger quart size. (willwolf)
Mmmm. I love this brand. It's so creamy, and delicious. I almost think the hazelnut is a bit overpowering, but maybe only because I know how good the chocolate is. If you don't like hazelnut, you probably won't like this, though. It's definitely very good. (AC)
Creme caramel
4.5 stars! This was lush, smooth and perfectly caramel.  There was not iciness to the cream and the flavor was perfect, that sugary buttery hint.  Very good.  It also had a nice vanilla undertone which I feel stepped up the caramel taste perfectly.  Very good and I highly recommend.  I will now be on the look out for more Whole Soy flavors to see if they are all up to this standard. (Cali)
4 stars. Light tasting but still plenty of caramel flavor. (fb)
OH.MY.GOD. This is outstanding. It's..perfect. The frozen yogurt is smooth and rich, with a perfect vanilla flavor, and the caramel is..amazing. It's ooey and gooey, and very caramely. I think there are layers of caramel, but I just got past the first layer. Love it. This is my favorite brand, btw. (AC)
French vanilla

Lemon ginger

Mocha fudge

Swiss Dark Chocolate
4!! This is so good! It really reminds me of Haagan Daz (AC)
Vanilla bean

Very strawberry

0 likes

yeah, I seem to be a soy ice cream veteran. But all these other reviews have made me realize how many flavors/brands I haven't tried. Ambitious goal for summer: eat all soy ice cream.

(ok, maybe not all kinds)

0 likes

yeah, I seem to be a soy ice cream veteran. But all these other reviews have made me realize how many flavors/brands I haven't tried. Ambitious goal for summer: eat all soy ice cream.

(ok, maybe not all kinds)

We should have a competition! Whoever tries the most flavours of soy ice cream by the end of the summer (September 21st) wins. They will then be crowned the venerable soy ice cream mastah.

What do you think?

0 likes

Has anyone ever seen a Celestial Seasonings (like the tea) brand rice milk ice cream?  It wasn't marketed toward vegans, but it was and it was deeelicious.  They had a Chocolate Chai with Caramel flavor that rocked my socks.  I haven't seen it in a while... was it a figment of my imagination or are there other witnesses?

0 likes

Has anyone ever seen a Celestial Seasonings (like the tea) brand rice milk ice cream?  It wasn't marketed toward vegans, but it was and it was deeelicious.  They had a Chocolate Chai with Caramel flavor that rocked my socks.  I haven't seen it in a while... was it a figment of my imagination or are there other witnesses?

never seen it!

0 likes

I'm surprised no one has mentioned purely decadents cherry nirvana holy shit, its the best.  I give it a 4!

0 likes

So i just googled the Celestial Seasonings ice cream... and I wasn't imagining it, they just changed the packaging.  and i get confused easily ::) ::).  It's Rice Dream now, and that Chocolate Chai Caramel flavor was the shit.  They also used to have a vanilla peach flavor that I never tried, and my memory has already given out as to whether or not I saw it on their website...

0 likes

We should have a competition! Whoever tries the most flavours of soy ice cream by the end of the summer (September 21st) wins. They will then be crowned the venerable soy ice cream mastah.

What do you think?

Butbut..it's expensive! I only have a couple of coupons left...and I don't know how long sales will last.... :o

0 likes

We should have a competition! Whoever tries the most flavours of soy ice cream by the end of the summer (September 21st) wins. They will then be crowned the venerable soy ice cream mastah.

What do you think?

Butbut..it's expensive! I only have a couple of coupons left...and I don't know how long sales will last.... :o

You're right... I never thought of this...  :(

0 likes

we have this thrifty grocery with lots of veg stuffs and they sell the big containers (not the little pints) of soy icecream for $1.99.....and on top of that they are buy one get one free! So really $1 each! I think the smaller pints are 1.49 buy one get one. Some are expired but who cares!

We lost power for 2 days this week and Noah and I had to eat a half of container of icecream before it melted....poor us!  It was vanilla and I mixed in peanut butter and chocolate chips.mmmmmmm

0 likes

I remember the celestial seasonings! i got chocolate chai caramel and hazelnut vanilla bars. They were pretty good, but not something I'd run back to the store for.

I forgot to mention (though not soy ice cream): Rice Cream (not Dream), now known as Rice Divine. Their carrot cake (yes!) flavor is DIVINE (haha), and I don't even normally like ricemilk or anything. 4!

0 likes

I forgot to mention (though not soy ice cream): Rice Cream (not Dream), now known as Rice Divine. Their carrot cake (yes!) flavor is DIVINE (haha), and I don't even normally like ricemilk or anything. 4!

I think I've seen that at a nearby HFS! Is it really that good? Maybe I should give it a try...

0 likes

if you like carrot cake, yes.

The ice cream itself is more just sweet carrot-y flavor with the tiniest hint of spice, and there are cute chunks of carrot cake (they should sell it separate!) in it. I swear, one week I thought that carrot cake ice cream would be a good idea, and the next it popped up at Trader Joe's.

0 likes

I remember the celestial seasonings! i got chocolate chai caramel and hazelnut vanilla bars. They were pretty good, but not something I'd run back to the store for.

I forgot to mention (though not soy ice cream): Rice Cream (not Dream), now known as Rice Divine. Their carrot cake (yes!) flavor is DIVINE (haha), and I don't even normally like ricemilk or anything. 4!

the one i get that is carrot cake flavored is called "good karma". Is that the same thing? They also have key lime flavor which is just as awesome!

0 likes

we have this thrifty grocery with lots of veg stuffs and they sell the big containers (not the little pints) of soy icecream for $1.99.....and on top of that they are buy one get one free! So really $1 each! I think the smaller pints are 1.49 buy one get one. Some are expired but who cares!

We lost power for 2 days this week and Noah and I had to eat a half of container of icecream before it melted....poor us!  It was vanilla and I mixed in peanut butter and chocolate chips.mmmmmmm

damn! good deal.

i've only tried a few kinds of vegan ice cream but the one that i tried first stands out as the best vegan or non-vegan ice cream i've ever had: Tofutti Butter Pecan, actually they call it "Better Pecan". probably one of the most unhealthy things ever (even as ice cream goes), but good for once in a while. i haven't even had this kind lately, i think i'll have to get some to see if it's still that good.

0 likes

I remember the celestial seasonings! i got chocolate chai caramel and hazelnut vanilla bars. They were pretty good, but not something I'd run back to the store for.

I forgot to mention (though not soy ice cream): Rice Cream (not Dream), now known as Rice Divine. Their carrot cake (yes!) flavor is DIVINE (haha), and I don't even normally like ricemilk or anything. 4!

the one i get that is carrot cake flavored is called "good karma". Is that the same thing? They also have key lime flavor which is just as awesome!

yup, same brand.

since they stopped selling it at TJ's I haven't kept track with the flavors, but if we have this summer-ice-cream-competition, then i'll be on it.

0 likes

OK, I have tried all of the above mentioned brands and don't care for any of them.  They don't taste natural at all.  I would rather have nothing than any of them!  I wouldn't even eat them if they were giving them away for free.  I have found the brand that whole foods carries (365 organics) vanilla and chocolate are excellent!  They have very few ingredients and really taste great.  I highly recommend the hot fudge from this site as a topping.  Most excellent...

0 likes

So Delicious Carob Peppermint is sooooo good and not too bad for you either (~115 cal for 1/2 cup)!  I've tried some of the other So Delicious flavors and didn't like them as much.  The chocolate peanut butter one just doesn't seem to have enough flavor.  I used the Trader Joe's vanilla soy ice cream for a shake and it was just ok - I would use it in a pinch but wouldn't seek it out.

Also, I recently tried the Temptation choc-chip cookie dough and that was the BEST soy ice cream I've ever had!  Too bad you can only find it in certain cities...

0 likes

Pages

Log in or register to post comments

More Posts Like This