You are here

Chinese Imports Highlight Woeful State of Consumer Safety

  Please consider doing what he asks in the article below- contact your congressperson and ask them to seek enforcement funds and to compel the mandatory labeling of all imported foods in compliance with Country of Origin Legislation passed in 2002. The possibility exists that we may be buying foods that are labeled organic or vegan that originate in China and aren't what they seem. I personally don't trust anything imported from there and would like to have the option of not buying it. Without the enforcement of mandatory labeling laws we have no way of knowing where our food comes from. A lot more than fish gets imported from China!

Chinese Imports Highlight Woeful State of Consumer Safety

by Ralph Nader

It has been a long time coming, but now the mass media and even the “look-the-other-way” Food and Drug Administration (FDA) are focusing on a stream of Chinese imports that are contaminated or defective.

After years of warnings about farm-raised seafood imports from the Chinese mainland, the FDA’s Dr. David Acheson, in charge of food protection, said: “There’s been a continued pattern of violations with no signs of abatement.” So, finally, the FDA in late June blocked the sale of shrimp, frozen eel, catfish, basa and dace. The reasons included carcinogens and too many antibiotic residues.

Crowded into ponds, farmed Chinese fish are breeding grounds for disease, lice and contaminated water. So heavy doses of antibiotics and other food additives-many illegal in the U.S.-are applied. China is a major exporter of seafood to the U.S. We import 80% of all our seafood.

In recent weeks, disclosures of hundreds of thousands of defective tires (tread separation problems), lead-coated toys, contaminated toothpaste and pet food (which destroyed about 6000 pets) have raised the profile of a situation which is likely to get worse.

China produces products in a horrifically polluted environment-of the water, air and soil. Industrial chemicals, farm run-offs, mountains of toxic waste are alarming Beijing for both domestic consumption as well as foreign trade reasons. Despite loud proclamations of forthcoming action, the Chinese government has waited too long, allowed too much corruption and lax enforcement, and condoned a huge industry in exported counterfeit goods where anything goes.

Although country-of-origin legislation passed Congress in 2002, Mr. Bush-obsessed by the costly Iraq war and indentured to large corporate importers-did not push his Republicans in Congress to provide funds for enforcement. Instead, the president has signed into law delays in the labeling rule. Therefore, except for the required labeling of seafood from foreign countries (consumers take note), all other food in your supermarket is not required to have a label of the country that exported it. It is the majority Democrats’ job now to compel mandatory labeling of all imported foods.

China is the largest apple juice exporter in the world. Apple juice from China is pouring into the United States. Is there anything left that cannot be imported into what was once the greatest food exporter the world has ever seen?

It gets worse. The U.S. is on the verge of becoming a net food importer!

China has allies in the U.S.-the giant food processors that love to rely on profit-maximizing Chinese foodstuffs, additives and other ingredients. The large wholesalers and retail chains, like Wal-Mart, buffer the Chinese export machine from long overdue inspections and enforcement actions.

The inadequate budget of the FDA, and its fractured role with other federal agencies such as the U.S. Department of Agriculture, contributes to the failure of consumer protection. The FDA 2007 budget is only $1.5 billion, or one third of the price of just one aircraft carrier. That is not enough to defend the health and safety of the three hundred million Americans from hazardous drugs and foodstuffs.

Especially since the FDA has weak or non-existent enforcement powers to obtain information, keep records, demand recalls or impose effective fines.

Presently, the FDA is able to inspect about one percent of food shipments into the U.S. What can consumers do? Start yelling at your Senators and Representatives. This is one issue they are afraid to duck if the heat is on them. Second, buy from farmers and other producers near you, so you can skip the long chain of middlemen from China to your area who could have caught the problem but just pass the buck, so to speak.

Farmers markets from nearby farms are one way you can avoid contaminated imports.

Eighty percent of all children’s toys in America come from China. They come with too many hazards-burning, choking risks for small children, toxics in or on the toys. Some are recalled by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. You can be automatically notified of all CPSC recalls by registering with http://www.cpsc.gov/cpsclist.asp.

But, really, the fundamental responsibility here is with Beijing and Washington when careless or criminal companies fail their responsibilities. There needs to be a consumer safety treaty between the two countries where consumer needs are supreme.

Consumer groups and advocates in China need encouragement from their U.S. counterparts.

As far as those half a million or more replacement tires on the U.S. highways-already linked to two fatalities, the U.S. distributor in New Jersey says it doesn’t have enough money to recall them all. What about the Chinese exporter?

What is the U.S. Department of Transportation going to do about what will become more such defect-caused tragedies from a flood of auto parts and tires imported from China and other countries?

Ralph Nader is a consumer advocate, lawyer, and author. His most recent book is The Seventeen Traditions.

These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.

Original located here:  http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/07/09/2409/

     

Thanks for  posting this!  I'l llook into the fine print morning in the morning.  It's almost midnight here.  :o

In case you're interested here are some previous links to posts on this subject:
Pet Food & Other Recalls From China
http://vegweb.com/index.php?topic=16317.msg113471
http://vegweb.com/index.php?topic=16349.msg108788

Recently in the Japanese news, they've had showed alot of problems with toys and imported veggies and other food products.  For food, it's usually along the lines of them having 2-4x the legal limit of pesticides.  Also stories about some of those who produce these things-forced child labor/child slavery. 

It's a sad state of affairs over there. :(  But since this is ALL about business, the USA, as a major importer demanding improvements can have an effect.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

0 likes
0 likes

Holy cats... anyone see this?

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/30/world/asia/30china.html?ex=1338177600&en=2e6d84cbbd48869d&ei=5088

  I had heard about the sentence. I think he's a scapegoat, the problems in China are probably institutional. Someone had to take the fall so their government could show the world how seriously they are taking the problem.

  By the way, he was executed today:

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2007-07/10/content_5424937.htm

0 likes

  I had heard about the sentence. I think he's a scapegoat, the problems in China are probably institutional. Someone had to take the fall so their government could show the world how seriously they are taking the problem.

I've got to agree with you on that.  He was just a sacrificial lamb, the problems in China are much larger than a single man. 

0 likes

I've got to agree with you on that.  He was just a sacrificial lamb, the problems in China are much larger than a single man. 

Heck yeah he's nothing more than a scapegoat.
It's like the brand new game show they have - you bring in your sentimental / treasured items and experts tell whether its a fake or not.  If it is  they break it on the spot.  they showed one teary-eyed contestant professing  "I was sad at first since my grandmother gave it to me but it's better that it is gone since it was an fake"

:o
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

0 likes

Heck yeah he's nothing more than a scapegoat.
It's like the brand new game show they have - you bring in your sentimental / treasured items and experts tell whether its a fake or not.  If it is  they break it on the spot.  they showed one teary-eyed contestant professing  "I was sad at first since my grandmother gave it to me but it's better that it is gone since it was an fake"

:o

  Sounds like one more idiotic show among many.

  Makes me think of the movie "Idiocracy" by Mike Judge. It shows a future where humanity has devolved into a bunch of complete idiots because for hundreds of generations stupid people have reproduced copiously while smart people have procrastinated because they take starting a family more seriously. Future humans sit around on couches with toilets built into them all day and watch television. The most popular show? It's called "Ow, My Balls" and shows home video after home video of people getting accidentally whacked in the nads.

  That's where we're heading, folks!

0 likes

  Makes me think of the movie "Idiocracy" by Mike Judge. It shows a future where humanity has devolved into a bunch of complete idiots because for hundreds of generations stupid people have reproduced copiously while smart people have procrastinated because they take starting a family more seriously. Future humans sit around on couches with toilets built into them all day and watch television. The most popular show? It's called "Ow, My Balls" and shows home video after home video of people getting accidentally whacked in the nads.

  That's where we're heading, folks!

Hilarious.

Yet probably terribly accurate.  :o  (I really shouldn't  laugh.)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

0 likes

Machiavelli said that absolute power will corrupt absolutely.  In this day and age, money is the absolute power.  Although so many pursuits are had in the name of God or religion, I think that even more are done in the name of money.  Whether money and wealth is perceived or actual, it seems to dominate the world. 

I was watching the BBC today and they were talking about global warming and the new study that states that the sun is not at fault, it is related to the earth not the sun activity.  They talked about where green house gases are coming from.  They showed cattle in China.  As the world becomes more affluent (or has that appearance) meat consumption goes up, and so do green house gases.  We may import our food from other countries, but we are exporting our habits and beliefs about it.

It is easy to point to the US.  We eat better (more calories available on the market), waste more food, use more gasoline, water and resources than any other country on the planet.  While you can't blame other countries, particularly China right now, wanting a piece of the Great American Pie, if there is one thing that the US should be exporting it is the notion that all of this prosperity comes with an environmental and health cost, and we are only beginning to understand the deeper costs...like multiple-drug resistant bacteria from too many antibiotics in animal feeds. 

Contaminated products from China should not be news to any of us.  I think it is just part of the disconnect of being human.  Yes, it is nice to have more money and eat better.  It seems to follow that that "better" entails animal products with their inherent health risks from obesity, to clogged arteries, high blood pressure and on and on.  We all seem to want what we want when we want it, no matter how many times it is hammered into us that it is bad.  It is like we all live in this never never land where actions don't have consequences.  It is like the smoking versus nonsmoking debate.  Every smoker knows it is a health risk to smoke.  What they do is fool themselves with the idea that it can't and won't happen to them because they will have quit before it can, but then they don't quit.  The longer nothing happens, the less likely it seems that it will, so why bother?  And you can translate this weight loss too.  I'll quit later. I'll lose the weight later. I'll make environmental changes later.  I'll worry about that later.  It does come time to pay the piper.

Our problems with China are multifocal.  They could outright own us, our trade deficit is so large.  They no longer make Levi's blue jeans in this country, they are made in China and elsewhere because it is so much cheaper to make them off shore.  Give us our All American blue jeans, but we don't want to pay an All American worker to make them, they need to be cheap.  You can't have just one pair or two, but you "need" 10.  More always seems like more, until it is less when you start to realize exactly what it is you have done.  The thing is, when we give those jeans to the Goodwill after we are done with them and buy another cheap foreign made latest style...they are more than likely sold to poor countries by the pound weight for resale in places like Africa and South America.  These cheaply made Chinese jeans go on to destroy clothing manufacturing in Africa too, and for about the same reasons it has happened in America.

I have been, for some time, looking at Chinese products as taboo.  They are often cheaper, more plentiful and widely available.  Because so few items from other places, particularly the US, are available, often the choice is buy Chinese or do without. 

They also become part of a vicious circle.  Factory jobs are lost in the US.  Consumers who once had some buying power now have a great deal less wherewithall.  Stuff from a $1 store means you can have some of things you once had, can treat your kids to something and make ends meet all at once.  Stuff from a $1 is coming from China and Taiwan, and the more you buy the more overseas factory jobs you stimulate, the fewer there are in the US and the less buying power the poor in the US have!

World economics are becoming more and more complex.  I am not sure of the answer, but I am starting to understand the question and many of the consequences.

0 likes

Ladydragonfly,

  Well said! The problems with China trade are very complex. It needs to be understood also that a great many of the factories in China are basically working for American and European investors that set up shop there for the cheap, nearly slave labor and the incredibly lax, practically non-existent environmental protection laws.

  The Bible says that the love of money is the root of all evil. I have felt for a long time that the world and most especially my home country the USA are being rapidly consumed by greed. How to get more money, more power, more material goods. No matter if these pursuits necessitate the destruction of the planet, the denial of health care to people who will probably die without it, the promotion of unsafe food, drugs, chemicals etc. As long as I get mine I have no need to worry about those things. They are problems too big for me to solve anyway. This seems to be the prevailing attitude in the world today.

  It's good to see that more and more people are starting to wake up. Vegans, environmentally minded people, progressives, etc. I keep hoping against hope that we will eventually be able to turn the tide (God, I hope Al Gore runs for president!). The chances grow slimmer IMO each day as political policies that aid in the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of fewer and fewer people continue to progress. Money buys media and media can and does manufacture consent for the people that own it in the "democracies" that it "serves". Money buys government as well and the people in government know who they need to serve if they want to stay in power.

0 likes

Good analyses. 

It's astonishingly little money he accepted.

If you think about the dairy and beef lobbies (or tobacco, or oil-- oy!) in the U.S.... well.  Yikes.

It amazes me that the economics of world trade transcend forms of government so thoroughly when it comes to corruption.

0 likes

Related article that just appeared today:

Italian Farmers Protest Food Labeling

by AP staffwriters

BOLOGNA, Italy — Tens of thousands of Italian farmers protested Wednesday against the lack of clear and detailed labels on agricultural products, saying cheap imports from China were hurting their bottom line.

Protesters marched through downtown Bologna demanding the implementation of a law approved by parliament last year that would force Italian companies to specify on labels the origin of the ingredients of foods and drugs.

The Coldiretti agriculture lobby, which organized the demonstration, said more 150,000 people participated.

Coldiretti said large-scale food-processing companies increasingly purchase raw foods abroad at low prices and mix them with Italian-grown products. The result is that it is becoming impossible to identify the origin of the contents of products such as fruits and vegetables, it said.

Such mixing has become a greater concern in light of recent scandals involving tainted products from China, a growing list that includes frozen fish to juice.

Farmer Claudio Pigini said his efforts to grow high-quality tomatoes are not rewarded because he is competing with cheaper foreign imports.

“We are limited in the usage of pesticides by Italian laws in order to avoid making the plant toxic. Having to comply with this rule involves a major expense. On the other hand, one doesn’t know what Chinese farmers use since they don’t do any tests,” Pigini told Associated Press Television News.

Copyright © 2007 The Associated Press.

Original located here: http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/07/12/2476/

0 likes

How's this for contaminated?

on the news this morning, they reported a resturant in china that was selling nikuman--the very very popular traditonal meat bun snacks all over asia--that was 60 percent cardboard!!!
:o :o :o :o :o

They interviewed the offender at this place and he showed how he and his family melted down the cardboard and chopped it up to mix with pork.  Of course his excuse was to 'cut costs'.

Over 20% of Japan's imports are from China.  :'( :'(

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

0 likes

How's this for contaminated?

on the news this morning, they reported a resturant in china that was selling nikuman--the very very popular traditonal meat bun snacks all over asia--that was 60 percent cardboard!!!
:o :o :o :o :o

They interviewed the offender at this place and he showed how he and his family melted down the cardboard and chopped it up to mix with pork.  Of course his excuse was to 'cut costs'.

Over 20% of Japan's imports are from China.   :'( :'(

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  I'm really starting to despise the whole filthy, greedy human race!  >:(

0 likes

How's this for contaminated?

on the news this morning, they reported a resturant in china that was selling nikuman--the very very popular traditonal meat bun snacks all over asia--that was 60 percent cardboard!!!
:o :o :o :o :o

They interviewed the offender at this place and he showed how he and his family melted down the cardboard and chopped it up to mix with pork.  Of course his excuse was to 'cut costs'.

Over 20% of Japan's imports are from China.   :'( :'(

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ferret Research:  http://ferretknots.blogspot.com/
Ferret Resources:  http://nippynihon.blogspot.com/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here's a link to the story: http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/asiapcf/07/12/cardboard.food.ap/index.html

0 likes
Log in or register to post comments