Naturally Nutty
Butter toffee peanut butter

Chocolate butter toffee peanut butter

Chocolate cherry peanut butter

Mocha peanut butter

Organic almond butter

Organic chocolate sunflower butter

Organic cinnamon vanilla sunflower butter
Very good.  The cinnamon is subtle and it's not too sweet.  You definitely need to like sunflower seeds because they have a particular taste. (icephrosty)
Organic peanut butter
Nothing special.  I won't buy this again because the peanut taste wasn't very strong. (icephrosty)
Organic pepita sun seed butter
Tastes like pumpkin pie in a jar, I love it!  The spice is so good in this stuff. (icephrosty)
Organic sunflower butter
I like this because it is differnt.  The texture is a little gritty because it is just sunflower seeds and salt.  There is a slight bitterness to it but I still thought it was good. (monkey7)
Organic vanilla almond butter
Tastes like icing.  Seriously.  I am in love with this almond butter and could eat it at every meal.  It makes a great sandwich with fresh strawberries and shredded coconut/coconut butter. (icephrosty)
Organic vanilla peanut butter
Delicious.  It's not as sweet as the vanilla almond, which is fine by me.  The jar I got had visible flax and I'm absolutely loving it.  These nut butters are worth the shipping cost!! (icephrosty)
White chocolate cherry almond butter

White chocolate coconut peanut butter

Nuts To You
I always buy the organic, and they's SO good... There's no added salt, sugar or oil, so it's just the pure flavor of the nut/seed. They dry roast rather than oil roast, so the taste is really clean. They do need to be stirred, since they don't have salt or oil, but I stir them once and they stay mixed nicely. So for anyone in Canada, or if you're visiting Canada, keep an eye out! (veganhealthy)
Almond crunchy

Almond smooth

Almond organic crunchy

Almond organic raw

Almond organic smooth

Almond raw

Almond cashew smooth

Almond fruit and nut crunchy

Almond hazelnut

Almnod hazelnut fruit and nut crunchy

Cashew

Cashew organic

Hazelnut

Macadamia

Macadamia cashew

Peanut cashew fruit and nut

Peanut hazelnut

Peanut smooth

Peanut organic crunchy

Peanut organic smooth

Pumpkin seed organic

Sunflower seed

Sunflower seed organic
My favorite. I love it on a rice cake with some blueberry jam  I've been using it in a lot of recipes lately, too - to thicken pureed soups, bean dips, salad dressing, etc... (veganhealthy)
Tahini

Tahini organic
awesome too, not as bitter as some other tahinis I've tried. (veganhealthy)
Valencia peanut crunchy

Valencia peanut smooth

Valencia peanut organic crunchy

Valencia peanut organic smooth

O organics
Peanut butter creamy
This is Safeway's (?) brand, so I'm trying to figure out how I got it at United. Anyway, it was ok...very creamy, but excessively oily. It really solidified on the bottom (AC)
Once Again Nut Butters
Cashew

Cashew organic

Almond butter natural crunchy

Almond butter natural omega 3 smooth

Almond butter natural raw smooth

Almond butter natural smooth

Almond butter organic omega 3 smooth

Almond butter organic raw crunchy

Almond butter organic raw smooth

Almond butter organic smooth

Peanut butter omega 3 organic smooth

Peanut butter old fashioned crunchy no salt

Peanut butter old fashioned crunchy salt

Peanut butter old fashioned smooth no salt

Peanut butter old fashioned salt

Peanut butter organic American classic crunchy

Peanut butter organic American classic smooth

Peanut butter organic crunchy no salt

Peanut butter organic smooth no salt

Peanut butter organic crunchy salt

Sunflower organic

Tahini organic
Not that great but it is the first time I had tahini by itself.  It is nice in hummus though. (monkey7)
Tahini
This is the most oily, nasty tasting (even in recipes), and over-priced tahini I've ever used.  Ick. (berryraw)
Peanut butter & Co.
Cinnamon raisin swirl
decent, but the raisin one, the raisins are hard and unfun. (bp)
This stuff makes AMAZING breakfasts!  I usually get whole wheat bread that has all sorts of fruits in it, toast it, and slather that delicious peanut butter on top.  (bloodywonder)
i thought was TOO cinnamony and yeah, the raisins were,meh...id save the bucks and make my own. (LA <3)
have been thrilled to be eating it on cin raisin bagels in the morning.  So far I have not run across a whole raisin but its creamy, spicy from the cinnamon and sweetly nutty.  Perfect in my book.  I keep contemplating on making oatmeal raisin cookies with some of that PB. 4 (cali)
awesome on toast but scares unadventurous eaters away. (cali)
It's just perfect (tweedle)
Crunch time
perfectly peanutty taste, enough peanuts that there is actually a crunch to it, not so much that you can't spread it. This is my favorite brand for peanut butter. (aggplanta)
Dark chocolate dreams
OH.  MY.  GOD.  That stuff is beyond sinful. (bloodywonder)
very dark...kinda bitter. but i guessif you like it... (LA <3)
We bought the Dark Chocolate and White Chocolate and I prefer the dark.  It is also mostly gone so I must extrapolate that Angel thinks it is supreme as well. 5 (cali)
AMAZING! i guess i am glad i didn't go w/ white choc. ha. i got it at wal-mart for like $3, which is funny because one: i never go to wal-mart but chose to set aside my loathing of wal-mart in favor of veganism  and two: this is the ONLY place i have ever seen these PBs. maybe i am just so used to my own shopping routine and rarely look for products like this. (hesp)
pretty good. (fb)
really good. (saskia)
nice but can get too sweet on a sandwich. (cali)
Yummy.  Very sweet.  I used it to make peanut butter cookies! (KMK)
too oily tasting to me (lebkuchen)
oh man oh man. It's definitely dark chocolate flavored peanut butter, not the other way around. It's quite stiff though (I had it refrigerated), but spreads fine on hot bread. (fb)
This stuff is good but not mind-blowing.  I have half a jar at home and I'm struggling to find enough uses for it. I don't really like this on sandwiches, so that limits the possibilities.  I think it's best suited for making PB brownies or just eating it straight out of the jar! (icephrosty)
I threw it out halfway through (tweedle)
I eat this when I am craving Nutella (not the same, but it cures my craving).  I always taste more chocolate flavor than peanut butter flavor.  I really like to use this in baking because it has common dessert baking ingredients all in one package! (dalveg)
This is delish! I've been looking for an alternative to Nutella, but I haven't been able to muster the courage to spend $15 to get the good stuff on veganessentials. Although this isn't quite it, it does fill the role I've been looking for. Could use a little more chocolate flavor, but I'm not complaining. Good deal for the price. (veganrun)
This was a nice change from regular peanut butter.  It is sweet (to me). (monkey7)
yum! I eat this on crackers, with pretzels, off a spoon. This isn't super strong dark chocolate to me--it's not going to kill a dark chocolate craving, but it totally squashes any cravings for peanut butter cups. I think if you melted down a peanut butter cup you'd get this.  (aggplanta)
I don't love this as much as I expected. I don't dislike it, but don't find it that special. Neither the chocolate or peanut butter flavor is spectacular. I didn't like it on a banana that much, as the flavor was muddled. It's better just on its own, but not something I feel compelled to eat. (AC)
Mighty maple
Mine was weird and grainy.  The flavor was just ok.  I was disappointed.  It tasted like it had sugar crystals in it that hadn't been mixed in. (KMK)
love it. I like the little crunchiness it seems to have from the maple syrup. (lebkuchen)
I really like this flavor a lot.  It is grainy, but I don't mind the maple sugar crunch.  I tend to use this more for breakfast...it's really great on pancakes or in stuffed french toast! (icephrosty)
Old fashioned crunchy

Old fashioned smooth

Smooth operator
a bit too salty for me, too. (tweedle)
Tastes like regular peanut butter.  The only reason I bought it was because it came in a single serving package.  It is better then Skippy's but not as good as MaraNatha. (monkey7)
again, fave brand, and it's nice and spreadable, not too oily  (aggplanta)
The heat is on
I thought the spicy one was repulsive!  My hubby loves peanut butter and loves all things spicy and even he hated it.  (thhf)
mega salty to me. i only use it (to use it up, i wouldnt' get more) to make quick peanut sauces. (bp)
WAY too spicy for me.  My partner really loves PB and spice so he thought this was a perfect combination.  I bet it would be great to use when making peanut curries.  I hope to try making one soon! (dalveg)
White chocolate wonderful
like the best stuff in the world (bp)
Ok, so on a scale of 1 to 5, 5 being super awesome and one being yucky yucky gross, the White Chocolate Wonderful would be… maybe a 3. At least at first, just a 3. It’s not so “Wonderful”… but it’s still very yummy. I think after a few tastes, it grew on me and got better. The smell of it reminds me of… I don’t know, but something. Maybe peanut butter/chocolate Halloween candy? Like Oh Henry’s or something? Brings back vague memories…I’d probably move the rating to a 3.5 or a 4. I like it, but I’m wondering if I would have like the cinnamon raisin better (I can always add my own raising, cinnamon, etc. so I’ve got not regrets). (laurabs)
i thought it was ok.. maybe if there were white chocolate bits mixed in or something to give a more intense white chocolate flavor.. it's made me leery of spending 5 bucks on another flavor, but if i had to choose id pick the dark chocolate one.  but then again i can add my own cocoa for free! (ppc)
it was just ok. it tastes like sweet peanut butter. i agree with propinecone about how it should have little white chocolate pieces in it. mmm that would be tasty. (ponycakes)
ok but not 'Must have MORE' to me. 3.5 (cali)
Sadly, I'd have to put the white chocolate at the bottom of my preference list, just because it's mostly like sweet peanut butter, with only a hint of white chocolate/cocoa butter flavor. But it's pretty good too, just maybe not worth the exorbitant price... (aziz)
bland but can stand up to being eaten on a sandwich or two back to back. (cali)
really like the White Chocolate one, which is why I don't buy it anymore because I would eat it straight outta the jar! (lebkuchen)
Just kind of sweet peanut butter. It's hard to taste much cocoa-butter-iness. It's fine though, but not worth the $5 I spent. (fb)
This is my favorite of all the PB&Co flavors.  It's really sweet and makes a great PB and banana sandwich!  It works well in desserts and isn't grainy at all, it's so smooth and easy to spread. (icephrosty)
i used to love it and eat it all the time, but after a while it got a little too sweet. but it's still good every once in a while. (veganhippie)
weird to me... (tweedle)
I thought this tasted like regular sweetened peanut butter (I normally eat natural peanut butters).  I didn't taste any white chocolate-ness at all... just sugary peanut butter-ness. (dalveg)
PB2 (Bell Plantation)
Chocolate PB2

PB2 Powdered peanut butter
I don't think I'd make a sandwhich out of it or eat it straight, although admittedly I haven't tried, but this is great for adding peanut butter flavor to things without all the fat.  I see they have a chocolate one too, but I haven't seen it around here. (lbarte)
Peter Pan
No sugar added creamy peanut butter

Plus creamy peanut butter

Reduced fat creamy peanut butter

Whipped creamy peanut butter

Smart Balance
Chunky rich roast
This was the first crunchy peanut butter I've had in years (I thought I didn't like it), and I loved it. Not too chunky, peanuty, good consistency. I like both of the Smart Balance pbs. (AC)
Creamy rich roast
mmm tastes exactly like the filling in nutter butters. (cammies)
I can't find a reasonably priced natural nut butter at the store, but this is the best I've found. It's very creamy, and doesn't have any weird flavor like Jif natural seems to have. I like it. (AC)
Skippy
Creamy peanut butter

Natural creamy
I bought this for a camping trip one time. It's plain ole peanut butter, but good. (AC)
the exact texture of traditional skippy or jif pb that you probably grew up with but without the scary hydrogenation.  it does have added sugar but overall it is probably alot healthier than original skippy.  it's delicious and ive converted more than a few people that were originally too scared to try natural peanut butter with it. (ppc)
Just plain ole PB taste.  Although, after eating organic PB this is not that great.  I use it in baking or when I run out of the good stuff. (monkey7)
This stuff is really good, the kind of PB that you can eat straight out of the jar.  Normally, I try to get PB with nothing added but this is soooo good. (icephrosty)
This is what I buy all the time currently, and I enjoy it. (AC)
Natural super chunk
Not bad for a plain jarred PB (I prefer the grind-your-own).  My family always seems to buy this kind, so I've had it a lot.  The chunks add a nice crunch.  (icephrosty)
I buy it all the time, and it's so cheap! (tweedle)
Good for baking. (monkey7)
Reduced fat creamy peanut butter

Reduced fat super chunk peanut butter

Super chunk peanut butter

Smuckers
Natural chunky

Natural creamy
Great flavor, good consistency, goes well in either sweet or savory dishes. (irreverent)
Natural no salt added creamy

Natural reduced fat creamy

Organic chunky

Organic creamy

Trader Joe's
Cashew butter
omfg delicious. This stuff is better than any stuff i've made from cashews, oddly. It has a bit of a grit to it though, but I don't mind - just FYI. (fb)
delicious and smooth. (veganrun)
Creamy unsalted smooth peanut butter
my favorite - just peanuts. smooth and tastes like high quality peanuts. Like any natural peanut butter, it has a tendency to separate. If you keep it in the fridge it won't separate any more, but it'll be really stiff, so... you decide. (fb)
good, regular, run of the mill pb. I like it. (veganrun)
I've been buying this pb for a while now, but I was on the review thread directory and thought I'd put in another word for this kind. It's tasty simple peanuts. Mine doesn't get that hard in the fridge, so my fridge temp might be a bit higher than fb's. (sog)
Peanut flour
It's not technically a nut butter but you can make it into one by adding liquid and stirring it up!  I've been seeing it all over the blog world lately so I decided to buy some.  It's around $3.50 for a whole pound, and it is very high in protein but not fat or calories.  I used almond milk to reconstitute it and then stirred it into my morning oats...t'was very, very good! (icephrosty)
Raw crunchy unsalted almond butter
oh yeah baby, this is the best stuff ever! I use it everyday on my toast and in all of my raw recipes, num num num! (lebkuchen)
Pretty darn good.  I really liked using this on crackers for a quick snack. (icephrosty)
I think this is actually my favorite almond butter. I love the texture. (veganrun)
Sunflower seed butter
another great one! Nice sweet flavor, verrrry smooth and wet (which is nice - it's not dry like some butters can be) (lebkuchen)
I like this, but it might be an acquired taste.  If you're really used to PB or almond butter, then it might be a shock.  I wish the jar came in a smaller size because a little goes a long way.  It is very spreadable but sometimes a little too runny. (icephrosty)
Woodstock Farms
Almond butter crunchy unsalted

Almond butter smooth unsalted

Cashew butter unsalted

Organic almond butter crunchy unsalted

Organic almond butter smooth unsalted
really good, but more expensive than TJ's brand, and I prefer TJ's brand anyway, especially since they have it in raw. (lebkuchen)
Organic classic peanut butter crunchy salted

Organic classic peanut butter smooth salted

Organic easy spread peanut butter crunchy salted

Organic easy spread peanut butter crunchy unsalted

Organic easy spread peanut butter smooth salted

Organic easy spread peanut butter smooth unsalted

Organic peanut butter crunchy salted

Organic peanut butter smooth salted

Organic peanut butter crunchy unsalted

Organic peanut butter smooth unsalted

Organic raw almond butter

Organic tahini unsalted
It worked well for tahini sauce and hummus, I'd definitely buy this again. (icephrosty)
Raw almond butter

Tahini unsalted