You are here

California Ban on Declawing--Press Release (this is kinda long...)

PRESS RELEASE:

West Hollywood's Groundbreaking Ban on the Declawing of Animals Upheld: News Conference to be Held on Monday, October 15, 2007
Thursday October 11, 7:07 pm ET

City of West Hollywood to Begin Enforcing Ban on Declawing of Animals

WEST HOLLYWOOD, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Yesterday, the California Supreme Court announced that it is refusing to review a decision by the California Court of Appeal upholding West Hollywood's ban on non-therapeutic declawing of animals. The City of West Hollywood will hold a news conference to address this issue and to announce its enforcement of the ban on the declawing of animals at 10 a.m. on Monday, October 15, 2007 at West Hollywood City Hall, 8300 Santa Monica Boulevard. The lower appellate court decision had concluded that the City's ground-breaking ordinance is a proper exercise of the City's police power and not in conflict with State law. West Hollywood's declawing ordinance is the first of its kind in California and sets a precedent for local government across the state.

"We are elated by the California Supreme Court's decision not to hear the appeal filed by the California Veterinary Medical Association (CWMA)," said West Hollywood Mayor John Duran. "From the time I introduced this ordinance, I was confident that protecting animals from mutilation was the right thing to do no matter who opposed it. Declawing amounts to amputation and we should call it what it is. Animals deserve the right to exist the same way they were born and not be "adapted" to meet people's needs," he continued.

Declawing involves removing not only the claw but also all or part of the last bone and connecting tendons and ligaments on an animal's paw. Many consider the procedure to be unnecessarily painful and cruel, and the procedure has been banned as a form of animal cruelty in numerous countries.

News conference participants will include Orly Degani, the lawyer who assisted West Hollywood in defending the ordinance in court; West Hollywood Mayor John Duran, who sponsored the declawing ordinance; and Dr. Jennifer Conrad, DVM of The Paw Project, who provided medical input regarding animal declawing to support the ordinance.

The California Veterinary Medical Association, a veterinarian trade group, challenged the West Hollywood declawing ordinance in court, claiming the ordinance was preempted by State law, and that West Hollywood has no authority to regulate the medical practices of veterinarians. West Hollywood disagreed with that position and defended the ordinance. A Los Angeles judge overturned the ordinance in 2006, ruling that cities lack power to limit the practice of state-licensed professionals. The court of appeal reversed the lower court decision, allowing West Hollywood's ban on animal declawing within its City limits to be enforced. The California Supreme Court has now denied CVMA's petition for review of the decision by the appellate court.

For more information, regarding the City of West Hollywood's Declawing Ordinance, please contact Hernan Molina, Deputy to West Hollywood Mayor John Duran, at 323-848-6460 or Tamara White, Public Information Officer, at 323-848-6431.

That's great! 
I wonder if that will open the door to allowing the banning of docking ears and tails of dogs (mutilating also) now, too.    ???

0 likes

They shouldn't do that declaw an animal.

0 likes

Yay! That's so great!  :)

It's rather sad that it is a veterinarian association that wants to challenge it. But then again, knowing what I know now about most vets, I guess I'm not too surprised.

0 likes

That is awesome! I wish Michigan would put a ban on declawing too--there are tons of apartments here that won't let you rent unless you declaw you animals! How insane is that?!?  >:(

0 likes

That's great! 
I wonder if that will open the door to allowing the banning of docking ears and tails of dogs (mutilating also) now, too.    ???

Yeah, I was hoping that, too, along with debarking--is that still legal in all states? I'm not sure...

0 likes

Wow, I'd not known of debarking!  I just googled it.  How sad!  :'(  Many of the sites say it doesn't affect the dog psychologically and the dog doesn't even know they're not able to really bark.  Yeah right!  How stupid do they think dogs are?  Any living creature would know if it could make noise one day then not so much the next day that something was wrong!  And how many of us would want our voices to be taken away from us involuntarily?   >:(     

Sorry for rant, just first I've ever heard of that.   >:(

**Although my dog is docked and cropped- ears and tail- I rescued him from the pound at 6 months old already cropped/docked.  I've had two other Dobies I (who've sinced passed away :'( ) who were cropped adult rescues, too. 

0 likes
Log in or register to post comments